|
Ledaig Ledaig
Sinclair Series, Rioja Cask Finish
ABV 46.3%
Comments: This is a really interesting mix of smoke and sweetness, layers wave over you one after another.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Smögen Smögen
8 Years Old
ABV 57.8%
Comments: Plenty going on here. Sweden, you keep us on our toes with things like this.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Abbey Whisky Abbey Whisky
Caol Ila
11 Years Old, 2008, AW Exclusive
ABV 54.2%
Comments: Interesting but doesn’t seem totally together. The smoke profile is lovely, though.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Dewar Rattray Cask Collection Dewar Rattray Cask Collection
The Macallan
1998, 9 Years Old
ABV 54.4%
Comments: Areal charmer.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Laphroaig
1998
ABV 58.7%
Comments: Good smokiness but seems to lack impetus.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Glenfiddich Glenfiddich
Malt Master's Edition
ABV 43.0%
Comments: What’s going on up in Dufftown?There seems to be a new ‘Fiddich every week –and on the strength of this that’s no bad thing.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Glenfarclas Glenfarclas
1953, The Coronation
ABV 51.1%
Comments: I liked this, despite the delicate levels of sulphur on the palate, there is still some life in this dram.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Ian Macleod Ian Macleod
Dun Bheagan
Islay, Aged 8 Years
ABV 43.0%
Comments: At their best, these are approachable, easy-drinking whiskies. This is a good example.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Ian Macleod Ian Macleod
Dun Bheagan
Lowland, Aged 8 Years
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Not quite the extra dimension that would raise it to the next level but great for a youngster.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Tullibardine Tullibardine
2005, The Murray
ABV 56.3%
Comments: It’s blunt and there’s something not quite right about the spirit underneath it all.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Sexton The Sexton
Single Malt
ABV 40.0%
Comments: It’s blunt and there’s something not quite right about the spirit underneath it all.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Berry Bros. & Rudd Berry Bros. & Rudd
Glen Elgin
1995, 21 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: This goes from nought to 100 in two seconds. One minute it’s vanilla softness, the next it’s gutsy and funky.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Wemyss Malts Wemyss Malts
The Glenrothes
1997, Chocolate Orange Segment
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Interestingly, rather than dominate and deaden the whisky, the vanilla adds a creaminess to the mouthfeel that really benefits those other zanier flavours.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Dalmore The Dalmore
Regalis
ABV 40.0%
Comments: The palate disappoints slightly by not offering a lot
more fullness.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
anCnoc anCnoc
Vintage 2001
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Nice, could do with being a touch more mellow to score higher.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Tomatin Tomatin
Cask Strength Edition
ABV 57.5%
Comments: Perfectly drinkable whisky, only the harshest of task masters would be disappointed with it.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Edradour Edradour
The Fairy Flag 15 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: This one isn’t quite to my liking.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Edradour, Straight from the Cask Edradour, Straight from the Cask
Chateauneuf du Pape Cask Finish, 11 Years Old
ABV 58.9%
Comments: It’s a young sherry monster, which could have come from anywhere.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Teeling Whiskey Teeling Whiskey
Single Malt Irish Whiskey
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A classic bourbon cask matured whisky. Springtime like, pleasant and refreshing. The pear flavour is so strong it almost tastes like a fruit spirit.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Douglas Laing Old Particular Douglas Laing Old Particular
Caol Ila
13 Years Old
ABV 48.4%
Comments: A pleasant springtime dram. Easy and enticing. But it needs water to be rounded up.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Maltman The Maltman
Ben Nevis
15 Years Old
ABV 49.5%
Comments: Classic and classy - I preferred it neat.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Scott's Selection Scott's Selection
Tomatin
1993
ABV 56.0%
Comments: Not a bad dram, a little water helps it reveal more on the palate.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Bowmore Bowmore
100 Degrees Proof
ABV 50.0%
Comments: Soothed with a dash of water. If you program this dram for a wake up call, you will soon be on your feet!
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The BenRiach The BenRiach
Septemdicem 17 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A full weight peaty character matured in a refill hogshead. Displays an assertive phenolic character but has not gained much from the cask.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Miyagikyo Miyagikyo
No Age
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Not at its best.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Scotch Malt Whisky Society
Littlemill
97.11 – 18 Years Old
ABV 56.0%
Comments: One for a long summers night, possibly with a light cigar.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Bunnahabhain Bunnahabhain
Darach Ur
ABV 46.3%
Comments: A well constructed dram but a bit stiff. I wish the alcohol was better mastered. A drop of water rounds it up a little but tends to add bitterness as well.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Machrie Moor Machrie Moor
The Peated Arran 2nd Edition 2004
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A moody offering from the Arran Distillery team.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Mackmyra Mackmyra
Special:05 Happy Hunting
ABV 47.2%
Comments: An enjoyable light but vibrant dram. Which will accompany a fish dish (add
a splash of water in your glass). Don't expect complexity. The cask did not
give much.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Lonach Collection The Lonach Collection
The Glenrothes
39 Years Old
ABV 42.7%
Comments: Reminds me of gentlemen's coconut oil shaving cream. If you like that,you'll love this.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Highland Park Highland Park
Artist Edition 1988
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A refreshing dram,quite balanced with a definite spicy character. To be enjoyed with a curried dish
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Bowmore Bowmore
16 Years Old Port Matured
ABV 53.1%
Comments: The palate is not as smoky as the nose. An interesting dram if not completely balanced.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Tomatin Tomatin
18 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: The nose is appealing but the sherry makes the palate a bit dour.
Would certainly warm you up on a frosty morning.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Highland Park Highland Park
Viking Honour, 12 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A very easy and pleasant whisky, one for the summer days with a little ice.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Malts of Scotland Malts of Scotland
The Glenrothes
1987, 22 Years Old
ABV 53.4%
Comments: There’s a lot here but it feels strangely compressed.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Woodford Reserve Woodford Reserve
Master's Collection, Straight Malt
ABV 45.2%
Comments: This would be good with food.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Wemyss Malts Wemyss Malts
Clynelish
1997, Spiced Chocolate
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Doesn't sing out as loudly as one would hope for - it's certainly pleasant, but not hugely exciting.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Ben Bracken Ben Bracken
Highland Single Malt
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Very approachable, and admirable layers.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Sullivans Cove Sullivans Cove
Double Cask
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Interesting. A touch green/bitter for my taste.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Glenlivet The Glenlivet
Master Distiller's Reserve Small Batch
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Another interesting and more complex departure from the ‘standard’ Master Distiller’s Reserve, but not sure it’s worth twice the price of the Solera Vatted expression.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Teeling Teeling
Small Batch, 4 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Not an unpleasant whisky but there is not much to explore. Water brings out more sweetness. Might shine through in cocktails really well.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Dalmore The Dalmore
Valour
ABV 40.0%
Comments: There is this odd strawberry aroma note on the nose. The palate is better structured but it could have benefited a higher strength I feel.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Glen Grant
1974, 37 Years Old, Cask #7643
ABV 47.8%
Comments: Clear signs of old age but well knitted together.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Glenfarclas Glenfarclas
1984 Plain Hogshead
ABV 46.3%
Comments: That whisky struggles to stand out among a flight of big sherry guys, but it is worth enjoying. Though we could have expected more character from a 27 Years Old whisky.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Scotch Malt Whisky Society The Scotch Malt Whisky Society
Rosebank
25.46 – Lemonade in a buttercup, 1991, 17 Years Old
ABV 56.1%
Comments: A frisky malt which tastes young. But too angular. Not a very fruitful maturation?
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Old Pulteney Old Pulteney
30 Years Old
ABV 44.0%
Comments: A dapper old gentleman but he won't set your world on fire.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Scotch Malt Whisky Society The Scotch Malt Whisky Society
Hakushu
120.4 – Tibetan Joss-Sticks and Polynesian Pork, 1990, 18 Years Old
ABV 59.3%
Comments: The nose is a delight. To enjoy the palate,you have to be a wood freak.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Dalmore The Dalmore
Castle Leod
ABV 46.0%
Comments: For those who like bitter drinks, obviously. Too much untamed wood maybe?
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Benromach Benromach
Burgundy Wood
ABV 45.0%
Comments: Give this whisky time to open on a sweeter side.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Isle of Jura Isle of Jura
1996. Boutique Barrel
ABV 54.0%
Comments: A rather dour fellow. Needs better balance for me.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Laphroaig
1998
ABV 59.5%
Comments: A pungent summer dram with character and simplicity. Strangely,
water makes it fiery. To try with oysters (just a drop please!).
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Tomatin Tomatin
1997, 12 Years Old, Single Cask No. 4326
ABV 57.1%
Comments: Lovely texture. The nose is a bit shy, the palate more expressive. Very correct but not terribly exciting.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Ian Macleod Ian Macleod
Dun Bheagan
Island, Aged 8 Years
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A model of consistency,with the same flavour and intensity,until the finish adds more variety.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Octave The Octave
Strathclyde
Strathclyde
ABV 50.4%
Comments: Straight into the autumns of my childhood here, sweeping leaves and digging potatoes.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Seven Seals Seven Seals
Peated Single Malt, Port Wood Finish
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Delicious and a good mix of savoury and sweet. The cask seems to have exerted a little too much influence on the liquid.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Da Mhile Da Mhile
Springbank
1992, 7 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Lively and refreshing, but the flavours have not combined and fleshed out as probably they will in another six or seven years.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Tantallan Tantallan
12 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Good flavours in the middle, but not very well rounded.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection
Old Pulteney
1994, Sauternes Wood Finish
ABV 45.0%
Comments: The nose is enticing, the palate disappointing. Funny enough, the heavy sweetness does not tame the alcohol bite.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Caol Ila Caol Ila
1979, 25 Years Old, Special Release
ABV 58.4%
Comments: Not instantly welcoming, this takes time to get to know... but it is worth the effort. Subtle complexities at work.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Wemyss Vintage Malts Wemyss Vintage Malts
Speyside
1995, Chocolate Heaven
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Slightly disappointing until the finish which is worth the entry price.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Highland Park Highland Park
Sigurd
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A little tired, this dram but very drinkable nonetheless.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Dalmore The Dalmore
Valour
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Unusual and quite mysterious – a light touch to it.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Slyrs Slyrs
Single Malt
ABV 43.0%
Comments: This whisky needs time to fully express itself. Oak is prevailing which makes the whisky unbalanced.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Auchentoshan Auchentoshan
Aged 10 Years
ABV 40.0%
Comments: At 10 years, Auchentoshan makes an expressive, eloquent claim to being the classic Lowlander.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Glendullan Glendullan
12 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Big in both body and flavours, but restrained and controlled throughout.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Tyrconnell
Single Malt
ABV 40.0%
Comments: By no means complex but not a single wayward note, either. Perhaps too one dimensional for some, this expression further proves what an excellent malt Cooley produces.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Auchentoshan Auchentoshan
21 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Gently restorative. Subtleties gradually become apparent. Not quite as complex as I remember it.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Yamazaki The Yamazaki
Aged 12 Years
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Impressive nose and excellent body is undone slightly by the untidy finish.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Auchentoshan Auchentoshan
Three Wood
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A lot of wood-derived flavours and aromas here. Has a certain swaggering style.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Rosebank
1990
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A teasing early freshness is the overture to a richer, modestly structured, conclusion.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Ledaig Ledaig
Aged 10 Years
ABV 43.0%
Comments: No complexity, but a pleasant peaty dram. A definite step up from the old bottlings with no age statement.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
James Eadie James Eadie
Aged 8 Years, Single Cask
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Lop-sided towards the sharper end of things. Bracing stuff…
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Berry Bros. & Rudd Berry Bros. & Rudd
Glentauchers
1996, 20 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: I really enjoyed the flavour journey, but the length just wasn’t there.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Wemyss Malts Wemyss Malts
Mortlach
1995, Flambé Fruit
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Fresh and fruity, then toasty and nutty, before getting down and funky. The epitome of 'flavour journey'.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
That Boutique-y Whisky Company That Boutique-y Whisky Company
Port Ellen
Batch 5
ABV 47.1%
Comments: Sweet, salty and smoky. Ticking all those Islay boxes.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Dalmore The Dalmore
Dominium
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A promising dram with a slightly disappointing finish.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Murray McDavid Murray McDavid
Tobermory
Benchmark, Aged 20 Years
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Perhaps hasn’t quite found its feet just yet.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Ardmore Ardmore
Triple Wood
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A very drinkable peated Highlander. Good to see Ardmore’s unique take on peated whiskies is gaining a much greater exposure.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Glenlivet The Glenlivet
Founder's Reserve
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Not a great deal going on here. Some bite, but never really sinks its teeth in.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Benromach Benromach
10 Years Old, 100 Proof
ABV 57.0%
Comments: Surprisingly easy to drink neat, the palate not as alcoholic as the nose suggests.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Balblair Balblair
2003
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Either a young whisky or a whisky matured in a tired cask. Not unpleasant but too thin. I can imagine it in a granité or as a thirst quencher in summer with lots of ice.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Auchentoshan Auchentoshan
Valinch 2012
ABV 57.2%
Comments: Pleasant in parts, but the oak hasn't been as friendly to this as you would have hoped.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Glenfarclas The Family Casks
Release IX, 1994, 17 Years Old
ABV 57.9%
Comments: Powerful, but fairly one-dimensional.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Scott's Selection Scott's Selection
Glenallachie
1993, 19 Years Old
ABV 55.6%
Comments: The nose is pleasant but the alcohol makes it too sharp. The same with the palate. The cask has not mellowed it enough.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The BenRiach The BenRiach
Sauternes Finish 16 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Lacks a little depth in the centre, but of interest.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Glenfarclas The Family Casks Glenfarclas The Family Casks
Release III, 1978, 30 Years Old, Cask No. 626, Plain Hogshead
ABV 57.6%
Comments: Decently balanced.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Wemyss Vintage Malts Wemyss Vintage Malts
Single Cask Release
1989, 20 Years Old, Fruit and Nut Fudge
ABV 46.0%
Comments: While this doesn't set the house on fire,it's eminently drinkable.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Glenfiddich Glenfiddich
Age of Discovery
ABV 40.0%
Comments: That farmyard profile is a bit too much. And the palate is dour though sweet.
Lacks balance.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Caol Ila Caol Ila
Moch
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Worth a look.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Gordon & MacPhail Gordon & MacPhail
Linkwood
25 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A dour character which lifts up on the nose but not on the palate.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Kornog Kornog
Sant Ivy 2011
ABV 57.8%
Comments: A refreshing whisky but needs water.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The English Whisky Co. The English Whisky Co.
Chapter 11, Heavily Peated, 3 Years Old
ABV 59.7%
Comments: So difficult to score an infant ! All I can say is that there is a potential.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Old Malt Cask Old Malt Cask
The Glenlivet
Aged 18 Years
ABV 50.0%
Comments: Perfectly acceptable malt from this Speyside great.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Balvenie The Balvenie
17 Years Old Rum Cask
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Poised and balanced.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Ballantine's Ballantine's
Christmas Reserve
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Tastes rather young but a pleasant and easy to drink dram. Just a little weak at midpalate.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Oban Oban
Limited Edition
ABV 55.2%
Comments: Gets there in the end but you have to work for it.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Caol Ila Caol Ila
10 Years Old Unpeated
ABV 65.8%
Comments: There is a great difference between the nose and the palate. The alcohol is really aggressive on the palate. Better with water but still vibrant.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
The Glenlivet
1982, 27 Years Old
ABV 52.2%
Comments: The nose is enticing but the palate is overwhelmed by the wood. And water exacerbates the astringency.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Single Malts of Scotland The Single Malts of Scotland
Aberlour
1992, 16 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A decent pick me up dram after work.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Cask of Yamazaki The Cask of Yamazaki
1990, Sherry Butt
ABV 61.0%
Comments: A classic example of how to use a sherry cask.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Whisky Fair The Whisky Fair
Cooley
1992, 15 Years Old
ABV 56.4%
Comments: Is that a young whisky? It gives an impression of greenness and something unripe. Water is a must.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Connemara Connemara
1992, 15 Years Old
ABV 50.5%
Comments: The nose tells more than the palate. An additional touch of sweetness to balance the spices would make all the difference.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
The Glenlivet
1971
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A little cramped on the palate but has personality.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Caol Ila Caol Ila
Unpeated Special Releases, 2007, 8 Years Old
ABV 64.9%
Comments: On the palate,much more like a fruit spirit (Pear Williams) than like a whisky.A bit grainy on the nose.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Whisky Fair The Whisky Fair
Caol Ila
1984, 22 Years Old
ABV 59.0%
Comments: Unusual take on a peaty theme, but it works well.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Wemyss Vintage Malts Wemyss Vintage Malts
Single Cask Release
1995, Chocolate Heaven
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Slightly disappointing until the finish which is worth the entry price.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Laphroaig Laphroaig
27 Years Old Vintage 1980
ABV 51.0%
Comments: A'wyniwyg'
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Dewar Rattray Cask Collection Dewar Rattray Cask Collection
Highland Park
1989, 18 Years Old
ABV 53.5%
Comments: Couldn't be more different from the other Highland Park. That's casks for you!
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Old Malt Cask Old Malt Cask
Dufftown
1977, Aged 30 Years
ABV 50.0%
Comments: Has a cleanliness and delicacy but lacking in impact overall. You expect complexity from old whiskies.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Tobermory Tobermory
Aged 10 Years
ABV 40.0%
Comments: The feel is what is the biggest improvement here.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Old Malt Cask Old Malt Cask
Ardmore
1977, 30 Years Old
ABV 50.0%
Comments: Oak is prevailing, especially on the palate. Lacks balance and charm.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Ledaig Ledaig
Sherry Finish
ABV 42.0%
Comments: Quite a rich and complex malt. Needs a long aeration to release it all.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Cardhu Cardhu
Special Cask Reserve
ABV 40.0%
Comments: The first nose is not promising then the sweet maltiness wraps it in a more pleasant dress. You've got to have a taste for sweet drinks.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Single Malts of Scotland The Single Malts of Scotland
Bunnahabhain
Aged 27 Years
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A welcome addition.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Yamazaki The Yamazaki
Aged 10 Years
ABV 40.0%
Comments: More about potential. For me this is too young and needs time to come together.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Fuji Sanroku Fuji Sanroku
18 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Very clean and precise. Charming.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Dalwhinnie Dalwhinnie
Aged 20 Years
ABV 57.0%
Comments: Try to get the dilution right.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Balblair Balblair
1989 Vintage
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Seems young, but very attractive.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The BenRiach The BenRiach
Curiositas Peated Malt, Aged 10 Years
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Well balanced. Though peaty it doesn't have the marine phenolics usually encountered on the coast.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Bruichladdich Bruichladdich
Aged 15 Years, Limited Edition
ABV 54.0%
Comments: The nose puts you off, the palate tries to make it up but the result is not exciting.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Tyrconnell Tyrconnell
Aged 14 Years
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A decent drink, but the port finish is the winner out of the trio.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Deanston Deanston
Aged 30 Years, Limited Edition
ABV 46.7%
Comments: An old malty number just about holding its own, but it hasn't gained hugely in terms of complexity.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Square Barrel Square Barrel
Aultmore
Aged 16 Years
ABV 49.0%
Comments: Cask driven and enjoyable without being particularly exciting.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Tomatin Tomatin
1962
ABV 42.2%
Comments: High maintenance. Beneath that sleek exterior beats a hard, one dimensional heart.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Queen of the Moorlands The Queen of the Moorlands
Bowmore
Rare Cask, 1995, Edition XII
ABV 57.2%
Comments: Nothing wrong, just bottled too early.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Dewar Rattray
Craigellachie
1989, 16 Years Old
ABV 54.7%
Comments: The different elements haven't been pulled together. A better cask would have given some order and control.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Harris Whisky Harris Whisky
Tamdhu
14 Years Old
ABV 58.5%
Comments: At last something to get to grips with.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The McGibbon's Provenance The McGibbon's Provenance
Lochnagar
1994, Over 11 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Better weight but ultimately this is still fragile.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Bowmore
1995
ABV 56.2%
Comments: A sunny malt. Quite sharp and spirity but a pleasant aromatic freshness. Could be a thirst quenching for some. Water does not cut all edges.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
The Glenlivet
1975
ABV 54.0%
Comments: This is a big mean mother whose youthful charms have been lashed into submission by oak.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Single Malts of Scotland The Single Malts of Scotland
Aged 14 Years, Bourbon Barrel
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A surprising character. A light aromatic profile with a heavy mouthfeel. A touch of water keeps the balance right.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Lonach Collection The Lonach Collection
Caperdonich
33 Years Old
ABV 41.9%
Comments: A well knitted dram. On the fruit side. More complex than it appears. Oak is well integrated. A pity such a treasure is lost!
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The McGibbon's Provenance
23 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Reminded me of old Calvados. Oak tends to overwhelm fruit but a wee dash of water tones it down. Very unpeated for a Port Ellen!
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Harris Whisky Harris Whisky
Aged 13 Years, Cask 7014
ABV 55.9%
Comments: Some attractive elements but a little clumsy and adolescent.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Ichiro's Malt Ichiro's Malt
Aged 20 Years
ABV 46.0%
Comments: The nose is more enticing than the palate. Water reduces the gap, bringing in a velvety texture.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Nikka Nikka
Miyagikyo, 1987, Cask No. 89714
ABV 61.0%
Comments: Another example of sherry domination. Where's the balance?
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Dewar Rattray Dewar Rattray
Bowmore
1991, 14 Years Old
ABV 59.6%
Comments: A little mucky on the nose when diluted.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Cooper's Choice The Cooper's Choice
Caol Ila
1991, 15 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Fell apart with water, but fun to tussle with neat.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Highland Park Highland Park
Aged 15 Years
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Balanced, as whiskies of this age should be but just too sweet for this palate.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Glengoyne Glengoyne
Aged 19 Years, Single Cask
ABV 55.8%
Comments: A nice fresh feel. But alcohol is not tamed. Water cools it down but takes the zesty kick away.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Glencadam
1991, 13 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A fine enough dram, but insubstantial compared to the others in this company.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Glengoyne Glengoyne
12 Years Old, Cask Strength
ABV 57.2%
Comments: Greater depth and apparent maturity than you'd expect from a 12 Years Old.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Talisker Talisker
Aged 25 Years, Special Release 2005
ABV 57.2%
Comments: Easier drinking with water, but for full effect...
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Edradour Edradour
Aged 11 Years, Straight from the Cask Madeira Finish
ABV 59.6%
Comments: Bags of cask character, and fine if you find finishes fun.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Gordon & MacPhail Gordon & MacPhail
Benromach
22 Years Old, Port Wood Finish
ABV 45.0%
Comments: Should the pink tangerine blush of this whisky hint at Bacchus? He may have glanced at the cask, but I can't find him in the glass.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Dun Bheagan Dun Bheagan
Littlemill
Aged 21 Years, Sherry finish
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Full flavours but slightly tired. A Lowlander for Christmas? Well, perhaps for Boxing Day.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Glen Ord Glen Ord
Aged 12 Years
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A well-balanced dram. Nothing lacking, nothing too much. Just pleasant.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Dalmore The Dalmore
Aged 12 Years, Black Pearl
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A rich sweet and fairly deep dram.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Whisky Exchange The Whisky Exchange
Glenfarclas
1974, 30 Years Old
ABV 50.5%
Comments: A lot of elegance and distinction but as if it has lost health. Surprisingly enough, waters boosts it.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Aberlour Aberlour
Warehouse No.1
ABV 59.1%
Comments: Decent.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Gordon & MacPhail Gordon & MacPhail
Glen Mhor
1979
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Good, but needs some oomph.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Gordon & MacPhail Gordon & MacPhail
Ardmore
1990
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A pleasant dram, especially with a splash of water but lacks nerve and buoyancy.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Douglas Laing Douglas Laing
Benrinnes
1990, Aged 14 Years, Single Cask Sherry Finish
ABV 50.0%
Comments: Needs a bit more in the middle.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Whisky Fair The Whisky Fair
Rosebank
1974, Aged 20 Years
ABV 55.8%
Comments: Some will love the combination of a cult malt, alcohol, great age and smoke but I'm not so convinced.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Dormant Distillery Company The Dormant Distillery Company
Glenglassaugh
1976, 27 Years Old
ABV 47.4%
Comments: A distinctive malt, but now slightly past its best.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Duncan Taylor Duncan Taylor
Caperdonich
1969, 34 Years Old
ABV 41.0%
Comments: Quite engaging, but just past its best.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Connemara Connemara
Aged 12 Years
ABV 40.0%
Comments: That lactic note overwhelms nose and palate. Not sure that a dairy whiskey is something to look forward to! Surprisingly, a dash of water makes more palatable.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Arran Malt The Arran Malt
Port Cask
ABV 57.5%
Comments: Initially it's fine, but ends up more port rinse than finish.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Duncan Taylor Duncan Taylor
Knockando
1980, 23 Years Old, Cask 1913
ABV 47.0%
Comments: Knockando is always a well-mannered whisky, although this expression seems a tad tired.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Connoisseur's Choice Connoisseur's Choice
Clynelish
1991
ABV 43.0%
Comments: That peachiness made me think of a Clynelish Bellini.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The McGibbon's Provenance
The Arran Malt
8 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: The spirit is still coming together. Would have been best kept in the cask for a few more years.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Fuji Gotenba Fuji Gotenba
Aged 18 Years, Single Grain
ABV 43.0%
Comments: All oak. Good oak, but oak nonetheless.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Karuizawa Karuizawa
Aged 15 Years
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Has maturity and masses of charm.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Gordon & MacPhail Gordon & MacPhail
Bladnoch
1991
ABV 54.8%
Comments: The nose is unusual, closer to a sour Chinese broth than a whisky! But the palate restores an expected floral Lowland freshness.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Signatory Signatory
Bladnoch
1974
ABV 50.6%
Comments: Lovely, but the oak is just maybe a little too firm.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
James MacArthur's Old Masters James MacArthur's Old Masters
Auchentoshan
10 Years Old
ABV 64.2%
Comments: Sweet and simple.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Connoisseur's Choice Connoisseur's Choice
Mosstowie
1979
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A nostalgic reminder of the Lomond still, though I had forgotten it could produce such sweet whisky.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Chieftain's Chieftain's
Littlemill
1984, Aged 18 Years, Rum Finish
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Pretty woody but has a certain rough-hewn charm.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Stronachie Stronachie
12 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: I have a vague family connection with the original Stronachie Distillery. Good to see the name back. A good aperitif.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Signatory Signatory
Cragganmore
1989
ABV 55.7%
Comments: Lacks the complexity you expect from Cragganmore.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Signatory Straight from the Cask Signatory Straight from the Cask
Laphroaig
Aged 11 Years, Port Finish
ABV 60.0%
Comments: Intriguing, but a little too much imposed sweetness for my taste.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Signatory Signatory
Caol Ila
Vintage 1981, Aged 22 Years
ABV 59.0%
Comments: Significantly drier than the other Caol Ilas sampled.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Celtic Heartlands Celtic Heartlands
The Macallan
1968
ABV 40.2%
Comments: Light but attractive.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Ledaig Ledaig
Aged 7 Years
ABV 42.0%
Comments: Direct. One to watch.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Bowmore Bowmore
Cask Strength
ABV 56.0%
Comments: A good introductory malt.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Dalwhinnie Dalwhinnie
29 Years Old
ABV 57.8%
Comments: Seems reluctant to open.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Gordon & MacPhail Gordon & MacPhail
Old Pulteney
Aged 8 Years
ABV 40.0%
Comments: All the elements are there but haven't knitted. Better with a couple more years in the cask.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Dun Bheagan Dun Bheagan
Mortlach
Aged 10 Years, Port Finish
ABV 55.0%
Comments: Mortlach is usually a supple, muscular malt. At ten years, this already seems a trifle tired.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Chieftain's
The Glenrothes
1992, Aged 10 Years, Port Finish
ABV 43.0%
Comments: The nose suggests this was in sherry before being in Port. Has Glenrothes character but a bit dry.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Glen Garioch Glen Garioch
12 Years Old, National Trust for Scotland bottling
ABV 47.4%
Comments: Approachable and enjoyable, but a little mild-mannered for me. Bring back the peat...please!
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Signatory Signatory
Brora
Un-Chillfiltered Collection 1981, Aged 21 Years
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Not sufficient drive being given by the cask.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Celtique Connexion Celtique Connexion
Speyside 1989, Sauternes Wood Finish
ABV 43.0%
Comments: The wood has a fair say in things, the Sauternes playing a subtle role in it all.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Magilligan Magilligan
1991, Sherry Wood Finish
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A boisterous, roistering, very quaffable malt.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Chieftain's Chieftain's
Littlemill
1984, Aged 18 Years
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A gentle, appealing drink.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
James MacArthur's Old Masters James MacArthur's Old Masters
Clynelish
1989
ABV 59.1%
Comments: A good one, though spoiled by that slightly grubby character.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Cadenhead's
Imperial
The Glenlivet 1977, 24 Years Old
ABV 57.6%
Comments: It wears its heart on its sleeve, and its big heart.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Bruichladdich Bruichladdich
1984 Vintage
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A good addition to an impressive range.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Signatory Signatory
Port Ellen
1979
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A rather pleasant dram but a paler version of Port Ellen.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Signatory Signatory
The GlenDronach
1976, Cask Strength
ABV 53.1%
Comments: An enjoyable malt, but Glendronach is capable of more.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Rare Malts Selection Rare Malts Selection
St. Magdalene
1998, Aged 19 Years
ABV 63.8%
Comments: For a ghost, quite aggressive.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Old Pulteney Old Pulteney
Aged 12 Years
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Mellow and accessible.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Mackillop's Choice
Tomintoul
1966
ABV 46.5%
Comments: Delicate, light and simple.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection
Caol Ila
1988, Sherry Wood Finish
ABV 40.0%
Comments: The sherry gives roundness but doesn't dominate Caol Ila's characteristic energy.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Connoisseur's Choice
Caol Ila
1988
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A good attractive introduction.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Glenmorangie Glenmorangie
1991, Sauternes Wood Finish
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Not easy to evaluate what sauternes casks have brought in. An extra sweetness maybe but no particular sauternes aromas. Appreciable bottling strength.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Glengoyne
Scottish Oak Finish
ABV 53.5%
Comments: A rather eccentric version of Glengoyne. Very distinctive. A digestive after Thai food or even a curry?
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Finlaggan
21 Years Old, Islay Malt
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Has mellowed with the extra years, but, as is sometimes the case with island malts, it seemed happier with the vigour of youth.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Chieftain's Chieftain's
Rosebank
1991, Aged 11 Years, Sherry Finish
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Straight down the middle of the palate. A nice drink.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Chieftain's Chieftain's
Brora
1982, Aged 19 Years, Sherry Butt
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Good, but it could be any heavily sherried malt. Lacks an individual personality.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Chieftain's
The Glenturret
Aged 10 Years
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Crunchy! Attractive.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Blackadder
Ben Nevis
1984, Raw Cask
ABV 61.2%
Comments: Rich and heavy. Plenty of nutty sherry-derived notes. It's good but just lacks complexity.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Auchroisk
10 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: This version is not obviously sherryish, but still manages very big flavours indeed. I'm very impressed.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Adelphi Adelphi
Royal Brackla
27 Years Old, Cask 5467
ABV 59.5%
Comments: Big and aromatic. There's bags of oaky character and not a lot of the distillery's. One to sip and ponder over.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Adelphi Glen Grant
1970, 31 Years Old, Cask 1036
ABV 55.4%
Comments: Old, venerable even, but only of historical interest.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Springbank Springbank
1992, 7 Years Old, Da Mhile Organic
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Has an extraordinary finish, suggesting something twice the age.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Deanston Deanston
17 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: An improvement from the 17 Years Old of old, which doesn't even begin to show its big age.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Bushmills Bushmills
10 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Lovely nose (once again). . Lacks a bit of depth (once again).
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Glendullan Glendullan
12 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A son of the soil. I would like to pit its spicy flavours against a good haggis.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
The Balvenie The Balvenie
21 Years Old Portwood Finish
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A decent and solid drop, not much to complain about here really.
OVERALL SCORE
7.7
Glen Breton Glen Breton
Ice, 10 Years Old, Single Malt Whisky
ABV 57.2%
Comments: Difficult to get my head around, an enigma as to its position in the market. Even diluted, it’s hard to discern any identity.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Glen Grant
1993
ABV 53.8%
Comments: No real depth or complexity.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Bakery Hill Bakery Hill
Classic
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Nicely made.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Lac'Holl Lac'Holl
8 Years Old
ABV 42.0%
Comments: A refreshing and delicate dram. Slightly fragile but it has its charm. Avoid water.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
The Wild Geese The Wild Geese
Single Malt
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A pleasant dram with a gentle character.On the fruit side. A perfect companion for a sweet. Close to the leader of the flock!
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Douglas Laing Old & Rare Douglas Laing Old & Rare
Bunnahabhain
1974, 34 Years Old
ABV 58.3%
Comments: Sherry bomb lovers will like this, but a little too much for me.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Highland Park Highland Park
Ragnvald
ABV 44.6%
Comments: The nose draws you in, the palate is a little one dimensional but the finish is exciting.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Master of Malt Master of Malt
Glenburgie
1992, 21 Years Old
ABV 0.0%
Comments: I prefer to dilute this one as it smoothes off the edges.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Talisker Talisker
25 Years Old
ABV 54.8%
Comments: Seems quite shy at first but a little drop of water helps it open up.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Convalmore Convalmore
32 Years Old, Special Release
ABV 48.2%
Comments: The wood just didn’t give much; lacks the diversity of flavours.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Caol Ila Caol Ila
Aged 18 Years, 'Unpeated Style' Special Release
ABV 59.8%
Comments: A bit samey.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Drambuie Drambuie
15 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: There is a trick here ! Can’t be a whisky. A whiskey liqueur for sure. So hard to score. Would be pleasant on ice. So, this is it, Drambuie!
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
SPEY SPEY
Fumare
ABV 46.0%
Comments: The main interest with this is the oily mouthfeel. A balanced, easy-drinking dram that I could drink a lot of in one sitting.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Lady of the Glen Lady of the Glen
Auchentoshan
1995, Aged 20 Years
ABV 54.3%
Comments: Tastes like lime pickle. Could have done with more time in the cask
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
The Glenturret The Glenturret
Peated Edition
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Quite a loud whisky but it needs to find its feet more.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Aultmore Aultmore
12 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Slightly puzzling at first but grew on me as I let it air.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Ancient Mariner Ancient Mariner
Tobermory
1996, 18 Years Old, Cask No. 349
ABV 46.1%
Comments: Solid enough, with masculine notes and a sweeter smoky centre.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Bunnahabhain Bunnahabhain
Ceòbanach
ABV 46.3%
Comments: Very easy drinking.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Bunnahabhain
1987, 26 Years Old, Cask #2728
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A rich and enticing whisky. Complex aromatic layers. Clean and crisp. Water enhances the citrus notes.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Darkness! Darkness!
Ardbeg
21 Years Old, PX Finish
ABV 40.1%
Comments: I wonder if this is a finish that may have had a little too long in its extra oak overcoat?
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
That Boutique-y Whisky Company That Boutique-y Whisky Company
Batch 2
ABV 46.0%
Comments: The palate does not deliver as much as the nose. Lacks character
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Mackmyra Mackmyra
Special 10
ABV 51.1%
Comments: Not unpleasant, but not without fault either. An enigma this one.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Tullibardine Tullibardine
Sovereign
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A nice dram with some interesting layers of flavour.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Speciality Drinks Speciality Drinks
Port Askaig
Cask Strength, 30 Years Old
ABV 51.1%
Comments: I would never have thought this is a 30 Years Old whisky. Very weird aromatic combination. Water brings them all together in a toffee tone.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Glen Garioch Glen Garioch
(A Rare Find) 1999, 12 Years Old, Cask No. 2906
ABV 58.2%
Comments: A shy and sleepy whisky. Water wakes it up a little revealing spices but it still lacks expression.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Longmorn
1992, 19 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Big and interesting, but seems to be all on the nose.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
The Balvenie The Balvenie
Tun 1401, Batch 5
ABV 50.1%
Comments: Up front sweetness at first but in time there is more than just sugar here.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Auchentoshan Auchentoshan
Heartwood
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Decent enough.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection
Linkwood
Cote Rotie, 1991, 20 Years Old
ABV 45.0%
Comments: For me the cask is over-dominant.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Wemyss Malts Wemyss Malts
Cragganmore
1989, Lemon Grove
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A cool summer dessert that acts as an ideal wake-me-up.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Duncan Taylor Dimensions Duncan Taylor Dimensions
Glen Moray
1994, 17 Years Old, Batch 1
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Pleasing but not sensational.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Glenfarclas Glenfarclas
1996 Sherry Butt
ABV 55.6%
Comments: The nose offered some smoothness that the palate denied. Not numbing
with water but gets bitter.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Speciality Drinks Speciality Drinks
Elements of Islay
Bn1 (Bunnahabhain)
ABV 57.7%
Comments: The nose is off-putting.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Mackmyra Mackmyra
The 1st Edition
ABV 46.1%
Comments: Mackmyra comes of age and it's good.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Scapa Scapa
16 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A little bit of a let-down after a superlative nose.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Wemyss Vintage Malts Wemyss Vintage Malts
Single Cask Release
1991, 18 Years Old, Flowers of Scotland
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Wemyss manage to produce highly quaffable bottlings. This is good but just lacks the cohesion that would elevate it to a higher level.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Wemyss Malts Wemyss Malts
Single Cask Release
1995, 14 Years Old, Spiced Apples
ABV 46.0%
Comments: The nose promised more sweetness than the palate delivered. A little
disappointing. Needs time to open.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
The Glendronach The Glendronach
Tawny Port 15 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: We all know 'Dronach is capable of better. This is a relic of an old regime.
Better things will come in the future.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Wemyss Vintage Malts Wemyss Vintage Malts
Single Cask Release
1988, Oak Apple
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Really that old? Perhaps it's a bit tired.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Glen Garioch Glen Garioch
1994 17 Years Old
ABV 53.9%
Comments: This whisky needs water to tame the alcohol. Pleasant enough.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Limeburner's Limeburner's
Barrel M40
ABV 61.0%
Comments: A strong character with a Deep South aromatic profile. I found the nose more convincing than the palate, still a bit spirit for me. But there are aficionados for flaming drams.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Benrinnes Benrinnes
23 Years Old
ABV 58.8%
Comments: You have got to like woody whiskies to drink this one. Has gone over the top for me. Certainly an old whisky but too long a maturation made it grumpy. Water kills it.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Mortlach
1991
ABV 56.4%
Comments: The sherry influence has wiped out the distillery character. What's the fun to inhale and drink oak juice?
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Battlehill Battlehill
Imperial
8 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A nice young Speysider and a curiosity:Imperial was mothballed 10 years ago.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Benromach Benromach
Traditional
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Better than I remember it. Spritely and light on its toes.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Ardmore Ardmore
Peated Malt
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A pleasant dram. No complexity of any sort,but a good outdoor companion for a barbecue or a walk in
the fields.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Brora Brora
30 Years Old Special Release 2007
ABV 55.7%
Comments: The nose is off-putting,which knocks the score down, but the palate delivers.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Glenfiddich Glenfiddich
Vintage Reserve 1976
ABV 51.9%
Comments: Elegant and stately,like a sophisticated old lady.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
The Dalmore The Dalmore
12 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Sweet and simple. Maybe higher alcohol would help?
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Seven Seals Seven Seals
Port Wood Finish
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Full of spices and promises. Would like to see a little more punch to it though.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Seven Seals Seven Seals
Sherry Wood Finish
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Great stuff and well worth getting your hands on.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Single & Single Single & Single
Bunnahabhain
1976, 31 Years Old
ABV 47.1%
Comments: There was so little in these last three samples that it’s hard to truly discern the whisky’s real qualities (or to retaste it, as is normal practise).
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Aberlour
1994
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A downy cheeked youthfulness. A delicious aperitif.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Powers Powers
Gold Label
ABV 43.2%
Comments: Unusual savoury characteristics which I liked.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Aberlour
10 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Lacks integration with the wood. Like some middle-weight malts, it needs time to reach full maturity.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Glenfarclas The Family Casks Glenfarclas The Family Casks
Release IX, 1983, 29 Years Old
ABV 51.0%
Comments: Very held back, but in time slowly reveals delicate layers of flavour.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Glenfarclas The Family Casks Glenfarclas The Family Casks
Release IX, 1975, 37 Years Old
ABV 54.7%
Comments: A well integrated whisky that is very appealing and wants you to keep trying it.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Knappogue Castle Knappogue Castle
16 Years Old, Twin Wood
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Nose and palate are completely different. The second saving the first. The palate shows a beautiful Irish character whereas the nose is bland. So drink it without nosing it.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Master of Malt Master of Malt
Cragganmore, 1991, 20 Years Old
ABV 54.2%
Comments: That whisky has obviously matured in a tired cask. The alcohol is not mastered. But the aromatic profile is not unpleasant.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Glengoyne Glengoyne
14 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Nothing really unlikeable, apart from that soft weakness. But nothing to get excited about. Water kills it.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Wemyss Malts Wemyss Malts
Longmorn
1997, 13 Years Old, Honey Harvest
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Not an unpleasant dram but it has matured in a tired cask and has
retained its new-make character. Disappointing for a 13 Years Old.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Malts of Scotland Malts of Scotland
Glenglassaugh
1984, 25 Years Old
ABV 54.7%
Comments: Another oak and oak only whisky. I must have an oak-(over)sensitive palate!
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Glen Moray
1981 Single Sherry Butt
ABV 57.7%
Comments: Sherry but(t) no Glen Moray.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Benromach Benromach
Organic
ABV 43.0%
Comments: The 'organic' bit feels like first-ism to me, and not as important as the 'virgin oak' part. The first new oak malt that has worked for me.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
The Single Malts of Scotland The Single Malts of Scotland
Clynelish
1972, Aged 32 Years, Cask 15619
ABV 49.9%
Comments: Simple blocks of flavour and aroma come together to form a whisky that might have benefited from a few more years maturation.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Chieftain's
Banff
1978, Aged 26 Years, Sherry Wood
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Too burnt and dry. Not for everyone. Reminds me of a particular espresso and grappa, standing outside the Arsenale, on a winter's morning.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Captain W. G. MacDonald’s Captain W. G. MacDonald’s
18 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Balanced and characterful.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Jura Jura
Aged 16 Years
ABV 40.0%
Comments: More wood-extract, or sherry, than I remember. I prefer a drier expression.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Glenfiddich Glenfiddich
12 Years Old, Special Reserve
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A young, light, uncomplicated dram. Drink over ice.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Highland Park Highland Park
Ambassadors Cask, Aged 21 Years
ABV 47.5%
Comments: A touch astringent for my tastes, but respectable. Ambassador, surely you should be really spoiling us?
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
James Eadie James Eadie
Aged 8 Years, Small Batch
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Summer on the farm. Questionable casks, but the underlying spirit is lovely.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Grindlay's Selection Grindlay's Selection
1996
ABV 57.0%
Comments: Tired wood, possibly, but an entertaining whisky despite that.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Glenfiddich Glenfiddich
Experimental Series No. 02, Project XX
ABV 47.0%
Comments: Approach-able, soft and safe.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Wemyss Malts Wemyss Malts
Bowmore
1989, Barbeque Mango Salsa
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Variation on a vanilla theme, this time with added smoke.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Box Box
Dálvve
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A vanilla ice cream float in cream soda.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Springbank Springbank
Cask Strength, 12 Years Old
ABV 54.3%
Comments: A little like kissing someone after smoking a cigar.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Glenfarclas The Family Casks Glenfarclas The Family Casks
Release IX, 1986, 25 Years Old
ABV 58.4%
Comments: You have got to like woody whiskies to appreciate this one. The sweetness
cannot balance the astringency.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Speciality Drinks Speciality Drinks
Karuizawa
Spirit of Asama
ABV 55.0%
Comments: Unfortunately, very one-dimensional.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Sullivans Cove Sullivans Cove
French Oak 11 Years Old
ABV 47.5%
Comments: Just slightly too much wood for me.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
The BenRiach The BenRiach
Solstice 17 Years Old Batch 2
ABV 50.0%
Comments: That cheesy note on the palate is disturbing. And the finish is harsh. Water smoothes it but tones the flavours down as well.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Ichiro's Malt Ichiro's Malt
Ten of Clubs 1990 19 Years Old
ABV 52.4%
Comments: The nose is more expressive than the palate which does not have the same elegancy and nuance. But still very drinkable.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Wemyss Malts Wemyss Malts
Mortlach
1990, Freshly Cut Grass
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Like No2 this is delicate but while that shows good distillery character this
just seems not quite fully formed. Pleasant, but pleasant isn't enough
after two decades.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Tomatin Tomatin
15 Years OId
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A good solid dram.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Duncan Taylor Duncan Taylor
Bowmore
1982, 25 Years Old
ABV 55.4%
Comments: Very strange. The nose and palate are miles apart.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Ben Nevis Ben Nevis
14 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Like the new Ardmore,an acquired but complex taste worth working on.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Wemyss Vintage Malts Wemyss Vintage Malts
Single Cask Release
1994, Glace Fruits
ABV 46.0%
Comments: There's a restrained quality about all of these. Amusing lunchtime companions.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Cadenhead's
Glen Ord
19 Years Old
ABV 57.0%
Comments: A good aperitif whisky. Great drinking.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Glengoyne Glengoyne
1972
ABV 46.0%
Comments: The nose promised smoothness, the palate delivered dry oakiness. Water cuts the edges but enhances bitterness and spices.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Inchgower
1980
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Choose the 1974 over this one, although if you are a fan of sherry cask led malt this may be your thing.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Dewar Rattray
Tomintoul
1975, 30 Years Old
ABV 48.5%
Comments: Slightly angular. Not a lot seems to have happened.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Douglas Laing Douglas Laing
Linkwood
1989, 16 Years Old
ABV 50.0%
Comments: An aperitif best taken by 10am. Has identifiable Linkwood character but it's all rather muted.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Dewar Rattray Cask Collection Dewar Rattray Cask Collection
Teaninich
30 Years Old
ABV 60.8%
Comments: The high strength makes it difficult to tame even with water. Some like it hot. But my palate waves a white flag.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Bowmore Bowmore
1990, Aged 16 Years
ABV 53.8%
Comments: The keynotes are the intense floral and a meaty sherryness, which aren't my favourite flavours in a whisky, but I can see this being popular with many.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Duncan Taylor Duncan Taylor
Glen Grant
1970, Speyside Region Selection No.2
ABV 51.7%
Comments: Too woody for me, but some people will adore its obvious 'old-ness'.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Dewar Rattray Dewar Rattray
Mortlach
15 Years Old
ABV 55.4%
Comments: The lack of interaction between oak and spirit makes this hard to get excited about.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Dewar Rattray Dewar Rattray
Bruichladdich
1993, 12 Years Old
ABV 55.1%
Comments: Complex, subtle and interesting, but not a dram to stay at home for. Go out, have fun!
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Glenmorangie Glenmorangie
Cote d'or Burgundy Wood Cask
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A beautifully balanced Highlander. Serious, reliable, pleasantly displaying a good array of flavours. Maybe the wine cask has imparted more intensity.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Benromach Benromach
21 Years Old, Finished in Hungarian Tokaji Wine Casks
ABV 45.0%
Comments: Inhaling provides 'aroma-therapy, ' while the palate shows that mixing the grape and the grain can be thoroughly rewarding and risk-free.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
James MacArthur's James MacArthur's
Bladnoch
12 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Gentle to the point of reticence. Aperitif. Or try it with Morrocan food.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Glenmorangie Glenmorangie
Speakeasy
ABV 58.4%
Comments: A frisky wee beastie.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
The Glenlivet The Glenlivet
Nadurra, 16 Years Old
ABV 48.0%
Comments: Delicate to the point of reticence.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Dewar Rattray Dewar Rattray
Benrinnes
Aged 14 Years
ABV 59.3%
Comments: Nose and palate are a bit agressive with a lingering sourness which is disturbing. A prickly character. Water smooths the flavours over but this is not enough.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Tomintoul Tomintoul
16 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Slightly more grainy and less fruity than I remember.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Glen Moray Glen Moray
1986 Commemorative Bottling
ABV 64.4%
Comments: Reminiscent of a slightly flabby Australian chardonnay.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Dewar Rattray Cask Collection Dewar Rattray Cask Collection
The Macallan
1989, Aged 14 Years
ABV 57.6%
Comments: A very odd Macallan. Perhaps a very odd cask.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Dewar Rattray Cask Collection Dewar Rattray Cask Collection
Auchentoshan
1990, Aged 13 Years
ABV 60.0%
Comments: Decent but lacking true balance.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Hokuto Hokuto
Aged 12 Years
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A pleasant summery dram. Keeps fruity all the way.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Rare Malts Selection Rare Malts Selection
Blair Athol
1975, Aged 27 Years
ABV 54.7%
Comments: Attractive but slightly flabby.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Glen Moray Glen Moray
Classic
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Seems rather neutral at first, but develops engaging subtleties.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Murray McDavid Mission II Murray McDavid Mission II
Caperdonich
1968, 35 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Good structure, but spoiled by bitterness and woodiness.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Cadenhead's Authentic Collection
The GlenDronach
Aged 13 Years
ABV 55.4%
Comments: Well balanced and gentle.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
The Arran Malt The Arran Malt
Single Malt Non Chill Filtered
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A curious inversion. As though the whisky (rich and sweet, but without penetrating flavours) provides the background, while the sherry and wood are the highlights.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Balblair Balblair
Aged 10 Years
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Approachable and well structured, with delicious flavours.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Isle of Jura Isle of Jura
Superstition, Aged 10 Years
ABV 45.0%
Comments: The nose is lively but the palate is put to sleep by sweetness.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Signatory
Clynelish
1989, South African Sherry Butt
ABV 58.7%
Comments: At the risk of being pedantic are you allowed to call it South African sherry?
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Mercian Mercian
1987, Aged 14 Years, Single Cask
ABV 58.7%
Comments: Good weight, wood is beginning to show.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
James MacArthur's Old Masters James MacArthur's Old Masters
Bladnoch
1992
ABV 58.5%
Comments: A two-sided malt, with two different expressions on the nose and on the palate. The alcohol needs to be tamed with water.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Glen Garioch
10 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: An everyday, mid-weight malt.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Celtique Connexion
The Glenlivet
Braes of Glenlivet 1985
ABV 50.0%
Comments: The cask character somewhat dominates this zesty but delicate whisky.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Cadenhead's Cadenhead's
Caperdonich
1977, 24 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Clean, dry. Perfectly drinkable.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Adelphi Adelphi
Clynelish
12 Years Old, Cask 3280
ABV 57.2%
Comments: Pungent and vibrant but lacks the beautiful Clynelish style.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Inchgower Inchgower
14 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A bit restrained initially, then unveils a charming vibrant sweetness. Well-balanced.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Dailuaine
16 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Almost too perfect. Beautifully put together, but not quite memorable.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Bunnahabhain Bunnahabhain
12 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Wood is overwhelming, especially on the palate. Water does not help at all.
Lacks balance and charm.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Blair Athol Blair Athol
12 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: About as uncomplicated as it gets. Has improved on recent years, though.
OVERALL SCORE
7.6
Smögen Smögen
Primör Revisited
ABV 68.2%
Comments: A wonderful combination of sweet and smoke.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Auchentoshan Auchentoshan
Three Wood
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A lovely delicate interplay of flavours, though the whisky struggles to make itself heard among the woods.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Nikka Nikka
From The Barrel
ABV 51.4%
Comments: More grip than the first three. More of a sensation than an eruption of flavour.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
anCnoc anCnoc
12 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Quite characterful and cheerful, especially on the nose. Try it with a fruit pudding.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Gordon & MacPhail Gordon & MacPhail
Glen Mhor
1979
ABV 40.0%
Comments: The flavours of a school sweetshop. I hope that does not get Glen Mhor banned in Boston.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Master of Malt Master of Malt
Tamnavulin
15 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Why bottle a 15 Years Old single cask at 40%?
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The McGibbon's Provenance The McGibbon's Provenance
Laphroaig
1998, 10 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: The smoke is in balance, but maybe just lacks a little extra complexity from the wood to lift the score.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Dewar Rattray Cask Collection Dewar Rattray Cask Collection
Laphroaig
1996, 12 Years Old
ABV 60.3%
Comments: Can’t help but thinking this would be better with more time in cask.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Cù Bòcan Cù Bòcan
Single Malt
ABV 46.0%
Comments: The nose is so much lighter than the taste – very one dimensional whisky.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Bowmore
Legend
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A light, young version, at a competitive price.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Bunnahabhain
12 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Appetising and remarkably refreshing.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The Yamazaki The Yamazaki
Aged 18 Years
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Big flavours, and a lot happening, but could be rounder.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Glenkinchie Glenkinchie
12 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A huge leap in quality from the old 10 Years Old.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Macleod's Macleod's
Speyside Single Malt, 8 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Fine in an undemanding way.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Highland Park Highland Park
Full Volume
ABV 47.2%
Comments:
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
St George Spirits St George Spirits
Baller Single Malt
ABV 47.0%
Comments: Incredibly unusual single malt. Interesting, but not something I could drink in vast quantities. ‘Curiouser and curiouser,’ cried Alice.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Lombard Lombard
1972 Ledaig
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Simple, light and drying. Sip on a hot summer's day when you fancy a whisky, but not the heft of most drams.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Wemyss Malts Wemyss Malts
Glen Grant
1995, Arbor In Bloom
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A slalom of a whisky – unexpected twists and turns.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The Glenrothes The Glenrothes
Manse Reserve
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Quite light on the palate; a very pleasant dram.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Few Few
Single Malt
ABV 46.5%
Comments: A very strange tasting whisky...this one is not for me.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Discovery Road Discovery Road
The English Whisky Co.
Four Lions
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A burning feel. Alcohol is not well mastered. And that oily note is not pleasant.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The Glendronach The Glendronach
Cask Strength
ABV 55.2%
Comments: Once you back the alcohol down with a little water this starts to reveal some hidden pleasures.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The Macallan The Macallan
The Flask, 22 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: The effect of water is funny. It hardens the nose and softens the palate at the same time.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Auchentoshan Auchentoshan
Springwood
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Once in the mouth things start to happen but a little too restrained.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Benromach Benromach
10 Years Old Cask Strength
ABV 59.9%
Comments: A light whisky, a bit sharp when neat. Mellows with water.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Glenfarclas Glenfarclas
1961 Sherry Hogshead
ABV 54.4%
Comments: Fascinating though the nose is there's just too much cask here which pushes everything towards the bitter end of the flavour spectrum.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The Dalmore The Dalmore
Gran Reserva
ABV 40.0%
Comments: This is the best of the bunch,but in general I find the construction of these
just a little too obvious.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Tamnavulin 1991 15 Years Old Tamnavulin 1991 15 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: The nose is not appealing. But the taste is interesting. Water improves the nose but not the palate.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Bunnahabhain Bunnahabhain
Manzanilla Sherry Wood 16 Years Old
ABV 53.2%
Comments: The nose is not inviting but the palate delivers interesting flavours.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The Dalmore The Dalmore
Sirius
ABV 45.0%
Comments: A very old whisky which has retained vigour but lost its balance. Oak is prevailing. To savour more like a piece of liquid history.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Cragganmore Cragganmore
1989 21 Years Old
ABV 56.0%
Comments: I'd want more for a 21Year Old. Disappointing.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
King Kar King Kar
Conductor
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A pleasant dram in spite of a weak development at mid palate.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection
Longmorn
1964, 46 Years Old
ABV 51.9%
Comments: I'm the biggest fan of Longmorn but here the distillery's lost in an oak forest.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Dewar Rattray Cask Collection Dewar Rattray Cask Collection
Glen Scotia
1992, 17 Years Old
ABV 54.9%
Comments: I had a suspicion at first nose. Then it seemed to open on rich aromas. But the palate unfortunately confirmed my apprehension. Can't see the point in drinking wood!
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Karuizawa Karuizawa
1986, Cask No. 7387
ABV 60.7%
Comments: Water does not help as it brings oak forward and enhances bitterness. Too stiff on the palate
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Douglas Laing Old & Rare Platinum Selection Douglas Laing Old & Rare Platinum Selection
Brora
1976, Aged 30 Years
ABV 55.1%
Comments: Surprising. The nose is more appealing than the palate. A cardboardy flavour when water added.Disappointing.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The McGibbon's Provenance
The Macallan
1998, 8 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Nothing much wrong here,but lacks complexity and depth. Too young?
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Old Malt Cask Old Malt Cask
Convalmore
1976, Aged 30 Years
ABV 50.0%
Comments: An unusually fragrant dram. Palate does not totally follow though.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Gordon & MacPhail Gordon & MacPhail
Old Pulteney
1990
ABV 59.4%
Comments: A shame. Pulteney is a weighty enough spirit to cope with European oak. Not this time though!
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Michael Collins Michael Collins
Aged in Oak Casks
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A little lacking in impact after such a big nose. Worth a look though.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The Single Malts of Scotland The Single Malts of Scotland
Highland Park
Aged 16 Years
ABV 46.0%
Comments: No better than average HP.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Cadenhead's Cadenhead's
Craigellachie
12 Years Old
ABV 58.3%
Comments: A very refreshing dram, most enjoyable for a summer evening (one can dream!). The alcohol is more aggressive on the palate.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Bruichladdich Bruichladdich
Redder Still, Cask Strength
ABV 50.4%
Comments: A plump fruity number.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Benromach Benromach
Peat Smoke
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Fresh and frisky. A welcome body warmer.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Connemara Connemara
Peated Single Malt Irish Whiskey
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Characterful, vivid but not complex. 'Tastes'
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Clynelish
1992
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Tight and hard to love.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Glenfiddich Glenfiddich
Aged 12 Years, Toasted Oak Reserve
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A bit of a let down after such a great nose. A very pretty whisky but higher alcohol might have given it better impact in the mouth.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Gordon & MacPhail Gordon & MacPhail
Linkwood
15 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Decent balance. Worth a look.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Dewar Rattray Cask Collection Dewar Rattray Cask Collection
Auchentoshan
15 Years Old
ABV 59.0%
Comments: A bit flabby and dry.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The Singleton of Dufftown The Singleton of Dufftown
12 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A perfectly pleasant dram, but lacking the finesse and complexity of the best on show here.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Dewar Rattray Cask Collection Dewar Rattray Cask Collection
The Macallan
16 Years Old
ABV 51.3%
Comments: A pleasant summery kind of dram.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Duncan Taylor Rarest of the Rare
Mosstowie
1975, 30 Years Old
ABV 48.1%
Comments: A difficult whisky to pin down. A tricky nose shouldn't distract from a pleasant enough palate.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Nikka Nikka
Miyagikyo, 1991, Cask No.117705
ABV 61.0%
Comments: Quite a nice refreshing dram when generously diluted.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Gordon & MacPhail Gordon & MacPhail
Old Pulteney
1990, Cask Strength
ABV 58.8%
Comments: A grumbly kind of cove.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Dewar Rattray Dewar Rattray
Longmorn
1984, 20 Years Old
ABV 54.0%
Comments: More appealing in the mouth than the nose would suggest, and benefits from water.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The Glenrothes The Glenrothes
Select Reserve
ABV 43.0%
Comments: It's a perfectly decent dram but not a patch on the great 'vintage' bottlings.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Chieftain's Chieftain's
Brora
1981, Aged 23 Years, Sherry Finish
ABV 46.0%
Comments: This is decent, just slightly dull.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The McGibbon's Provenance The McGibbon's Provenance
Braeval
1996, Over 8 Years, Sherry finish
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A fragile dram. Interesting.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The Arran Malt The Arran Malt
Non Chill Filtered
ABV 46.0%
Comments: More a summery malt than a warmer-up. Pleasant but not captivating. Mid-palate is a bit weak.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The Glenlivet The Glenlivet
15 Years Old, French Oak Reserve
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A very pleasant summery dram. Quite fragile though. Water tends to wipe out flavours.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Benromach Benromach
1969
ABV 40.0%
Comments: An old-fashioned whisky for an old-fashioned winter's evening. Wins points for being cuddly rather than complex.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The Cooper's Choice
Rosebank
1992, 12 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Like lace on the palate. Treat carefully.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Douglas Laing Old & Rare Platinum Selection
Ben Nevis
1963, Aged 40 Years
ABV 45.0%
Comments: Just about holds its own against the effects of excessive age. On the cusp!
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Signatory Signatory
Linlithgow
1975
ABV 51.5%
Comments: Attractive, but just a touch insubstantial, lacking the texture and flavour range to make it great.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Glenfiddich
Caoran Reserve, 12 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A more sprightly Glenfiddich than the standard 12. Thirst-quenching. Peatiness and the smoked finish aren't as 'distinct' as the label suggests.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Signatory Silent Stills Signatory Silent Stills
Glencadam
29 Years Old
ABV 52.5%
Comments: This whisky used to remind me of strawberry shortcake. This bottling turns me toward tiramisu.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Signatory Silent Stills Signatory Silent Stills
Banff
34 Years Old
ABV 50.1%
Comments: Just too woody for me.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Bowmore Bowmore
Dawn, Port Casked
ABV 56.0%
Comments: Complex and curious!
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Old Malt Cask
Bowmore
1991, Aged 12 Years
ABV 50.0%
Comments: A good aperitif. Strangely like a Rockley Still rum.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Murray McDavid Mission II Murray McDavid Mission II
Glenlossie
1975, 28 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A rare chance to taste Glenlossie but, again, the wood gets in the way.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Yoichi
1989, Single Cask
ABV 60.8%
Comments: Again, very fruity, but lacking in other flavours.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Signatory Signatory
Aberfeldy
1978
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Less structure than the youthful version from the distillery or the more mature choice, but enjoyable in its own right. As a dessert malt with trifle?
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The Cask of Yamazaki The Cask of Yamazaki
1993, Bourbon Cask
ABV 58.0%
Comments: A good addition to the range, maybe just a little young.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The Speyside The Speyside
10 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A gentle warm-hearted glassful.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Signatory
Millburn
1983
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Confusing aroma, but otherwise the most enjoyable Millburn I have tasted.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Old Pulteney Old Pulteney
15 Years Old, Millennium Edition
ABV 0.0%
Comments: More distillery character than a 15 Years Old identified as 'sherry-aged'
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Mackillop's Choice
Linlithgow
1982, Cask 1336
ABV 62.6%
Comments: Lovely weight and carries its age well (though dies a bit quickly in the glass).
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Karuizawa Karuizawa
Aged 12 Years
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Can't quite get over that odd nose.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Gordon & MacPhail Gordon & MacPhail
Inverleven
1985
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Beyond the stark, disappointing nose, this is a genuinely fine dram. The star turn is the balance.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Glenmorangie
Three Cask Matured
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A very unusual vatting (bourbon, plain charred oak and Rioja) has produced equally strange flavours. Less oaky vanilla and more Rioja than I would have expected. I like its eccentricity, but it loses points for lack of whisky character.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Dalwhinnie Dalwhinnie
1981, Distillers Edition, Oloroso Sherry
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Beautiful interplay and balance.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Cadenhead's
Convalmore
1977, 21 Years Old
ABV 64.4%
Comments: Straightforward. Needs a splash of water, but much smoother than expected.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Blackadder Blackadder
Longmorn
1973
ABV 56.9%
Comments: A beast of a dram. Another case of Longmorn versus wood which has been won by the latter.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Bladnoch Bladnoch
10 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A decent dram where the oak dominates nicely.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The Arran Malt The Arran Malt
4 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A lovely whisky for one so young. What will it be like at two or three times this age?
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Knappogue Castle
1993
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Hugely drinkable. Young but sweetly vibrant.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection
Caol Ila
1998, Claret Finish
ABV 40.0%
Comments: There are times when whiskies can be just a little too gentle....and this is one.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Ileach
Single Malt
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Like Finlaggan, this must come from one of the Islay distilleries. It seems bigger, more rounded, but less assertive, than Finlaggan.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Murray McDavid
Bunnahabhain
1979, Sherry Cask
ABV 43.0%
Comments: For an allegedly light malt, the flavours sing through but, as the dark colour suggests, there really is too much wood.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Gordon & MacPhail
Caol Ila
1981
ABV 62.7%
Comments: Can't put my finger on it: it's okay, but a bit boring and passionless for a Caol Ila.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Aberlour
21 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: 11 years ago I tasted some 10 Years Old Aberlour and wasn't too impressed. It has matured through well but not all the kinks have been ironed out, especially towards the finish.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Talisker Talisker
1986, The Distiller's Edition
ABV 45.8%
Comments: Not for Talisker purists, but a highly distinctive interplay of whisky and sherry.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Isle of Jura Isle of Jura
10 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A lovely aperitif.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Rare Malts Selection
Cardhu
1973, 25 Years Old
ABV 60.5%
Comments: A very pleasant dram which shows Cardhu in its usual ultra-genteel light. Hardly complex, but a delightful dram from first to last.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Balblair Balblair
Elements
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Gentle, but complex as the flavours open.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Gordon & MacPhail Gordon & MacPhail
Ardmore
1985
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Big and old fashioned feel.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Number One Drinks Company Number One Drinks Company
Karuizawa
Cask #7290, 1972, 37 Years Old
ABV 65.0%
Comments: Glossy and substantial with a slightly bitter undertow.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Master of Malt Master of Malt
Bowmore
1983, 26 Years Old
ABV 53.4%
Comments: Perfumy on the palate as well as on the nose. Quite surprising. Very pleasant until the soapy flavour develops.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The Solaria Series The Solaria Series
Whisky Illuminati
Royal Brackla
ABV 68.0%
Comments: For me this is pushing the acceptable boundaries of ABV. This is not a neat sipper, but with water there is a lovely huge sherry bomb under there lurking.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Raasay Raasay
While We Wait
ABV 46.0%
Comments: The peaty medicine box is balanced by creamy characters, but vegetal quirk marks it down.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Bowmore Bowmore
Vault Edition First Release
ABV 51.5%
Comments: Millions of peaches, peaches for me.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Lombard Jewels of Scotland Lombard Jewels of Scotland
1979 Sherrywood
ABV 50.0%
Comments: Hopping mad.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Master of Malt Master of Malt
Single Cask Series
The Dalmore, Single Cask
ABV 55.5%
Comments: Decent enough but a little underwhelming.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Wemyss Vintage Malts Wemyss Vintage Malts
Single Cask Release
1996, 13 Years Old, Smoked Cheese
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Good but lacks mid-palate weight.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Tomatin Tomatin
1988, 21 Years Old
ABV 52.0%
Comments: The cask has left a dour print on this whisky. Too grumpy for me.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Wemyss Vintage Malts Wemyss Vintage Malts
Single Cask Release
1994, 14 Years Old, Honey Comb
ABV 60.0%
Comments: One of the better sweet lemon whiskies in a new release batch full of them.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Old Malt Cask Old Malt Cask
Bruichladdich
Aged 18 Years
ABV 50.0%
Comments: Does any distillery produce sweeter, cleaner malt than this one?
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Blair Athol Blair Athol
Limited Edition
ABV 55.8%
Comments: Not spectacular but a solid and enjoyable malt and a pleasant
ambassador for a distillery which rarely gets the limelight.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
The Whisky Society The Whisky Society
Springbank
1992
ABV 52.6%
Comments: Fiery. Lacks balance and character. Water cuts the edges but does not improve the aroma delivery.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Seven Seals Seven Seals
Single Malt Port Wood Finish, Cask Proof
ABV 58.7%
Comments: The elements separately are great but needs a bridge from each of them to be more balanced.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Penderyn Penderyn
Rich Oak
ABV 50.0%
Comments: Pleasant flavours feel somehow trapped, somewhat genie-like, within the spirit.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Tomatin Tomatin
Legacy
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A surprising dram. There is plenty of fruit but also, a spirit feel although it is not strong. Just as the cask had not given much. But the colour is not pale... Well? It tastes young anyway.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Dalwhinnie Dalwhinnie
Aged 25 Years
ABV 52.1%
Comments: A decent well balanced dram.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Glenfarclas The Family Casks Glenfarclas The Family Casks
Release IX, 1991, 20 Years Old
ABV 57.1%
Comments: I think this one has let the wood gain the upper hand, unfortunately.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Connemara Connemara
Sherry Finish
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Needs time to cheer up. A rigid oaky profile. Surprisingly,water softens it.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
Auchentoshan Auchentoshan
18 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Good nose,but the palate is a little too dry.
OVERALL SCORE
7.5
|
