|
Gordon & MacPhail
18 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: The best Benromach I have tasted. I wonder what she should expect in a few years from the new stillhouse.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Lady of the Glen Lady of the Glen
Glen Elgin
800180/2008 Hogshead, Tawny Port
ABV 56.8%
Comments: A good example where colour is not an indication of what to expect. A decent drop indeed.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Wemyss Malts Wemyss Malts
Linkwood
1995, Summer Breeze
ABV 46.0%
Comments: The aromatics are almost railroaded by the spices… but not quite. In the end, it comes up smelling of roses.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Gordon & MacPhail Gordon & MacPhail
Mannochmore
21 Years Old (bottled for The Whisky Shop Dufftown)
ABV 48.8%
Comments: All spirit and oak.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Limeburners Limeburners
Sherry Cask, Cask Strength
ABV 61.0%
Comments: Really promising stuff.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Bunnahabhain
1990, 21 Years Old
ABV 53.1%
Comments: A bold statement, this one. If you like heavily sherried drams, this will appeal, if not, perhaps time to reconsider.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The BenRiach The BenRiach
Importanticus Fumosus Tawny Port Finish
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Worth a look.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Highland Park Highland Park
1998
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Balanced and lightly complex.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Glendronach The Glendronach
15 Years Old 1995 Moscatel
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Soft and easy -and sweet -but all in all a little bland.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Balvenie The Balvenie
Signature
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Best neat and further proof of Balvenie's premier league status.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Whisky Society The Whisky Society
Clynelish
1992
ABV 58.5%
Comments: Great balance . Aperitif or with (sea)food.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Single Malts of Scotland The Single Malts of Scotland
Aged 25 Years
ABV 54.7%
Comments: Lovely balance. Great everyday dram.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Cardrona The Cardrona
Growing Wings
ABV 61.2%
Comments: Has the swagger of youth to it but also some serious quality.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Abbey Whisky Abbey Whisky
Anon
Batch 3, 30 Years Old, 1988, AW Exclusive
ABV 46.6%
Comments: Plenty of punch with excellent spices kicking the tastebuds into life.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Edradour, Straight from the Cask Edradour, Straight from the Cask
1997, 10 Years Old, Chateau d'Yquem Cask Finish
ABV 57.7%
Comments: I was expecting more fruit from a sauternes finish but I don’t mind nuts and chocolate.Water enhances the spices and oakiness but takes the luscious chocolate note out.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Cadenhead's Duthies Cadenhead's Duthies
Auchentoshan
19 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Well put together. Recommended.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Whisky Exchange The Whisky Exchange
Glengoyne
1990, 19 Years Old
ABV 59.6%
Comments: Sleek and languorous. An excellent mature whisky.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Glenrothes The Glenrothes
Minister’s Reserve
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Classic whisky making has given this a tight flavour, if not a little lacking in personality. Very easy to drink.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Master of Malt Master of Malt
Single Cask Series
Springbank, 19 Years Old
ABV 55.5%
Comments: A buoyant character. Perfect to get you back on your feet on a crispy morning.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Lambay Whiskey Lambay Whiskey
Single Malt
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Reminiscent of eating honey sandwiches in a peach grove.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
he GlenDronach
Revival, Aged 15 Years
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A good warming dram for the autumn, good balance with the spices.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Wemyss Malts Wemyss Malts
Craigellachie
2002, Spiced Apple Strudel
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Looks light in colour, but there is a darker side lurking here too.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Lagavulin Lagavulin
Aged 12 Years, Special Release
ABV 56.5%
Comments: A weird whisky, and a bit unbalanced, but it mostly works.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Gordon & MacPhail Discovery Gordon & MacPhail Discovery
Miltonduff
10 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Takes you one way, then another, but all becomes clear in the end.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Griffo Griffo
Stony Point
ABV 47.0%
Comments: A big sweet-toothed number mixed with corn notes.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Lombard Jewels of Scotland Lombard Jewels of Scotland
Speyside
Single Cask
ABV 61.5%
Comments:
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Caribou Crossing Caribou Crossing
Single Barrel
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A little one-paced.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Alchemist Alchemist
The Macallan
18 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A solid performer with good balanceand character.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Rampur Rampur
Vintage Select Casks
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Unexpected, but great. The lightness of touch and florality are intriguing. Avoid adding water – it dulls the nuances.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Dalmore The Dalmore
Valour
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Perfectly drinkable, but perhaps a lack of complexity.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Grindlay’s Selection Grindlay’s Selection
Ben Nevis
1997
ABV 52.6%
Comments: I’d say this would be perfect with cheese, in place of the quince jam.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Old Pulteney Old Pulteney
1989
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Flighty, not fighty, this whisky isn’t Champions League. It’s Sunday League.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Knappogue Castle Knappogue Castle
16 Years Old, Sherry Finish
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A work in progress and a shame to have been cut off in mid-development.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Highland Park Highland Park
Freya, Aged 15 Years
ABV 51.2%
Comments: A classic Bourbon cask maturation. Refreshing and satisfying. A good springtime malt to enjoy with smoked salmon.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
That Boutique-y Whisky Company That Boutique-y Whisky Company
Tobermory
Batch 1
ABV 53.8%
Comments: A pleasant example of a good Bourbon cask maturation. A good companion for a fish dish as well.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Glenfarclas The Family Casks Glenfarclas The Family Casks
Release X, 1965
ABV 57.8%
Comments: A lovely sherry hand grenade.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Glenfarclas The Family Casks Glenfarclas The Family Casks
Release X, 1958
ABV 43.7%
Comments: Wooded and a bit of a bruiser, but works on many levels. One for the sherry heads.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Old Pulteney Old Pulteney
40 Years Old
ABV 51.3%
Comments: The sherry dominates on the oaky side. Too much for me but if you like woody corpulent whiskies, this one is for you.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Speciality Drinks Speciality Drinks
Elements of Islay
Bw1 (Bowmore)
ABV 52.9%
Comments: A great restorative dram post dinner.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Wemyss Malts Wemyss Malts
Caol Ila
1996, Lemon Smoke
ABV 0.0%
Comments: Well balanced with lots of layers of sweetness and peat.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Royal British Legion The Royal British Legion
Glendullan
1999, 12 Years Old
ABV 58.8%
Comments: Layers of flavour emerge once the alcohol prickle is knocked back with water.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Glenfiddich Glenfiddich
Vintage Reserve 1974
ABV 46.8%
Comments: Surprising, refreshing, light and aromatic, quite hot on the tongue. A sort of ginger ale cocktail!
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Amrut Amrut
Two Continents Second Edition
ABV 50.0%
Comments: Amrut are doing some really interesting work right now.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The BenRiach The BenRiach
Arumaticus Fumosus Dark Rum Finish
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A constantly shifting but balanced mix of sweetness and smoke and
distillery character.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Dalmore The Dalmore
50 Years Old
ABV 52.0%
Comments: An old whisky which has stayed too long in wood. It was certainly beaming a good 10 years ago.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Ichiro's Malt Ichiro's Malt
Ace of Diamonds 1986 22 Years Old
ABV 56.4%
Comments: Intense and packs a considerable punch.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Glencadam Glencadam
1978 30 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Good, but for me just lacks the extra layer of complexity to lift it to the next level.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Glen Grant Glen Grant
1992 Cellar Reserve
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Floaty and summery.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Glann Ar Mor Glann Ar Mor
2005, 3 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A restorative whisky, despite its age.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Wemyss Malts Wemyss Malts
Single Cask Release
1997, 12 Years Old, Autumn Leaves
ABV 46.0%
Comments: An easy drinking dram with reasonable complexity.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Tomatin Tomatin
Decades
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A well balanced dram. With a good malty heart.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Linkwood Linkwood
26 Years Old. Wine Cask
ABV 55.5%
Comments: Oak is leading the way but in an elegant way. A very spicy dram. To be matched with a beef stroganoff maybe.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Glendronach The Glendronach
14 Years Old Virgin Oak
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Full and rich.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Caol Ila Caol Ila
25 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Great nose but a little dry on the tongue.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Wemyss Vintage Malts Wemyss Vintage Malts
Single Cask Release
1970, 30 Years Old, The Almond Tree
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Quietly understated. An Edinburgh lawyer (but with a personality).
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Caol Ila
1996
ABV 56.8%
Comments: Another marine fellow. Straightforward,muscular but not assertive. Invigorating.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Macallan The Macallan
Edition No. 6
ABV 48.6%
Comments: A perfect dram for apple day, or any day for that matter.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Bruichladdich Bruichladdich
Octomore 10.2
ABV 56.9%
Comments: Great balance. One to accompany a bacon sandwich I would say.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Duncan Taylor Rare Auld Duncan Taylor Rare Auld
Invergordon
1965, 40 Years Old
ABV 50.3%
Comments: An interesting profile. Well matured. The butyric note on the nose does not echo on the palate.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Dewar Rattray Cask Collection Dewar Rattray Cask Collection
Glenglassaugh
1973, 34 Years Old
ABV 52.0%
Comments: Good but delicate.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The GlenDronach The GlenDronach
Revival 15 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A palate whisky.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Malts of Scotland Malts of Scotland
Laphroaig
1996, 12 Years Old
ABV 58.5%
Comments: The best of this trio but lacks interactive maturation.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Caol Ila
1979
ABV 53.1%
Comments: A very engaging dram that needs a quiet night and a wood fire.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Speciality Drinks Speciality Drinks
Elements of Islay
Lg1 (Laphroaig)
ABV 56.8%
Comments: A morning uplifter. To be enjoyed with cream and porridge on a dricht day !
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Master of Malt Master of Malt
Glen Garioch
1993, 20 Years Old
ABV 58.8%
Comments: A contemplative – very three dimensional dram.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Old Pulteney Old Pulteney
Aged 12 Years
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Forget about the first nose and enjoy that luscious exotic profile. But no water, thank you.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Old Pulteney Old Pulteney
Aged 12 Years
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A complex and distinctive malt.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Bruichladdich
10 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Best as a wake-up call at 10am.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Caol Ila Caol Ila
Cask Strength
ABV 55.0%
Comments: A young, in-your-face style that still has some complexity. Really delivers on the palate.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Dalmore The Dalmore
Aged 21 Years
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Charms on the nose but a bit too oaky.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Dalmore The Dalmore
Cigar Malt Reserve
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A bling-bling dram. Goes wonderfully with cigars! (and fur coats and gold jewellery).
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
That Boutique-y Whisky Company That Boutique-y Whisky Company
Aultmore
Batch 5
ABV 48.8%
Comments: It reminds me of eating syrup waffles on Bonfire night.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Old Pulteney Old Pulteney
12 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Big and punchy. A good sipper. A lovely orange thread runs through it too.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Tomatin Tomatin
Earth Edition
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Moves from light to dark as you go through from the nose to the finish. Has lovely balance all the way.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Lombard Jewels of Scotland Lombard Jewels of Scotland
Glenallachie
1992
ABV 56.7%
Comments: Spicy, big and bold. Water helps it find its more refined edges and also lengthens the spice notes out.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Tullibardine Tullibardine
The Murray Châteauneuf-du-Pape Finish 2005 Vintage
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Straight down the line, no messing dram.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Shelter Point Shelter Point
Artisanal Single Malt Whisky
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Simple in a very good way; as in it’s a delight to drink and makes you want more.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Abbey Whisky Abbey Whisky
The Glenrothes
2006, Single Cask #5469
ABV 67.1%
Comments: A game of two halves, two totally different personalities with water and neat.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Lombard Jewels of Scotland Lombard Jewels of Scotland
Auchroisk
Single Cask
ABV 56.8%
Comments: Almost pure jalapeno juice at first, water brings a more agave sweetness to it. A whisky possibly for a Bloody Mary?
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Glenlivet The Glenlivet
Code
ABV 48.0%
Comments: Something for the midsummer, gentle heat and great spices. Lovely stuff.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Highland Park Highland Park
Dragon Legend
ABV 43.1%
Comments: Amazing nose, but didn't come through on the palate.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Ardbeg Ardbeg
An Oa
ABV 46.6%
Comments: A bit of a let-down, if I’m honest.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Scott's Selection Scott's Selection
The Macallan
1989, 22 Years Old
ABV 49.0%
Comments: A clean, light and fresh example.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Murray McDavid Murray McDavid
1989, Mission Gold, Aged 26 Years
ABV 50.4%
Comments: Greener than I’d expected, but a solid dram from the Queen of the Hebrides.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Glenfiddich Glenfiddich
Experimental Series No. 01, IPA Experiment
ABV 43.0%
Comments: As much as I like American oak, it was too dominant on the palate for me.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
anCnoc anCnoc
Rùdhan
ABV 46.0%
Comments: An accomplished mainland peated single malt.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
PUNI PUNI
Nova
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A Jack of all trades whisky.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Cù Bòcan Cù Bòcan
Bourbon Cask
ABV 46.0%
Comments: This is a very light product, erring a little too much on the side of sunflower oil.
Not quite enough body or depth, but a very easy drink.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Berry's Own Selection Berry's Own Selection
Glen Garioch
1989, 24 Years Old, Cask #7857
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Enjoyable, a great sipper as
a beginning to the evening dram.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Wemyss Malts Wemyss Malts
Invergordon
1988, Caribbean Crème
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Mor whisky, this will have wide appeal but may not be what single malt fans are after.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Glendalough Glendalough
Single Malt Whiskey 13 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Well rounded, with a touch of dominant oak.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Dunville's Dunville's
VR Old Irish Whiskey
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A straight bat this. Perhaps erring on the youthful side, but with some pleasant vibes alongside.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Mackmyra Mackmyra
Moment Bärnsten
ABV 49.8%
Comments: Entertaining but it just lacks some sweetness to balance the alcohol and rye.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
That Boutique-y Whisky Company That Boutique-y Whisky Company
Caol Ila
Batch 1
ABV 45.8%
Comments: An easygoing, straightforward and gently uplifting mariner.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Highland Park Highland Park
Loki, Aged 15 Years
ABV 48.7%
Comments: An oaky character, slightly dour at first but opening on fruit and toffee. Be light when adding water.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Wemyss Malts Wemyss Malts
Aultmore
1982, Sugared Almonds
ABV 46.0%
Comments: The persistence of time has been kind to this, up to a point. Some lovely fruity creaminess if you can get past the oak.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Mackmyra Mackmyra
Special:07 Hope
ABV 45.8%
Comments: A refreshing and clean whisky. Ideal to pair with seafood or shellfish: scallops, sushi or langoustines.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Bruichladdich Bruichladdich
Islay Barley 2004
ABV 50.0%
Comments: Young, a bit fiery but very refreshing. A summertime dram.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Glenfarclas Glenfarclas
1971 Sherry Butt
ABV 51.0%
Comments: Too long a maturation. When oak dictates the aromatic profile, it is hard
to feel satisfied.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The BenRiach The BenRiach
16 Years Old 1995 Cask 7164
ABV 58.3%
Comments: This whisky is oak dominated. Too much for me as we have lost the distillery character, but the nose is expressive. Beware of water, it kills it.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Glencadam Glencadam
1983 25 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: The palate has more to deliver than the nose. But oak prevails too much.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Glenfarclas The Family Casks Glenfarclas The Family Casks
Release III, 1987, 20 Years Old, Cask No. 3826, Refill Sherry Butt
ABV 53.2%
Comments: A lovely dram. Characterful and satisfying. For the adepts of slow drink. Water kills it.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Scotch Malt Whisky Society The Scotch Malt Whisky Society
Longmorn
7.51 – Sweet, Rich & Fruity, 1984, 26 Years Old
ABV 57.4%
Comments: Balanced and fine. Worth a look.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Balvenie The Balvenie
Golden Cask
ABV 47.5%
Comments: A satisfying dram. Very smooth and well-balanced. Oak is melting with
fruit. More character without water.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Eddu Eddu
Gold
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Well put together. Oak is well integrated. Deserves paying attention. To be paired with a dry ewe cheese like amanchego.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Glen Spey Glen Spey
1988 21 Years Old
ABV 50.4%
Comments: It has a sweet punch and some will love this overtly oaky style. I'm not wholly convinced about what it's done to the overall balance.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Glenugie Glenugie
Deoch an Dora 1977
ABV 55.4%
Comments: Disappointing for a 32 year-old sherry character I think.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Port Ellen Port Ellen
8th Release, 1978, 29 Years Old
ABV 55.3%
Comments: A solid performer but not in the same league as the 1982 25 Years Old.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Speciality Drinks Speciality Drinks
Elements of Islay
Lp1 (Laphroaig)
ABV 58.8%
Comments: Islay in a glass,it will take you back there instantly.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Gordon & MacPhail Gordon & MacPhail
Inverleven
1990, 17 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: One for those hazy lazy summer nights we are hoping for.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Auchentoshan Auchentoshan
Select
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Good balance. Fresh and exciting.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Balblair Balblair
1986
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Nothing sophisticated but an easygoing summer dram to sip on a warm day. A Scottish pastis.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Longrow Longrow
CV
ABV 46.0%
Comments: I have a bit of a blind spot when it comes to Longrow.This is a revelation.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Compass Box Compass Box
Canto Cask
Cask No 46, 10 Years Old
ABV 53.2%
Comments: A subtle dram which keeps on the cereal and fruit side,with a radiant lightness. Alcohol is perfectly mastered.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Oban Oban
20 Years Old
ABV 57.9%
Comments: Excellent balance given the age - wood hasn't overpowered it.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Tullibardine
1993, Sauterne Wood Finish
ABV 46.0%
Comments: There's lots of elements at play here. They're just not playing together.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The BenRiach
Aged 15 Years, Madeira Wood Finish
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Balanced and with good weight. A good addition to the range.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Glenfiddich Glenfiddich
Aged 21 Years, Gran Reserva
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Delivers more than expected. Seems a bit bland at start but it displays an attractive array of aromas and flavours on time. The rum influence is under control.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Balvenie The Balvenie
Roasted Malt, Aged 14 Years
ABV 47.1%
Comments: Give this time and you'll find a delicious dram.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Whisky Fair The Whisky Fair
Clynelish
32 Years Old
ABV 58.6%
Comments: A muscular yet elegant old malt. Brisk and complex. Alcohol is somewhat insistent.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Springbank Springbank
9 Years Old, Marsala
ABV 58.0%
Comments: Bags of flavour and a good duel between cask and spirit.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Douglas Laing Old & Rare Platinum Selection
The Macallan
Aged 28 Years
ABV 48.2%
Comments: Have this without water. Hinting at complexity.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Kirin Kirin
Fuji-Sanroku, 18 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: For those who like cider rather sour than sweet! interesting combination for a whisky cooler. A refreshing aperitif.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Karuizawa Karuizawa
1988, Aged 17 Years
ABV 59.3%
Comments: Sherry masks the distillery character. Fine if you are a big fan. That sickening sweetness with water added is questionable.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Celtique Connexion Celtique Connexion
1993, Monbazillac Wood Finish
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Composed of two distinct parts that add up to an impressive and balanced total.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Dewar Rattray Cask Collection Dewar Rattray Cask Collection
Balblair
1990, 19 Years Old
ABV 61.8%
Comments: A rich multi layered whisky which, surprisingly, I enjoyed better without water. The latter enhances a bitter tone.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Bruichladdich Bruichladdich
Aged 15 Years, Second Edition
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Elegant and seductive, while also offering depth and range.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Cooper's Choice The Cooper's Choice
The Glenlivet
1991, 13 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Well balanced if just a little oaky.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Glenfarclas Glenfarclas
105
ABV 60.0%
Comments: A bold character. Rich, sherry-armoured. Dangerously palatable even without water.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Douglas Laing Douglas Laing
Caol Ila
1979, Aged 25 Years
ABV 50.0%
Comments: Austere but with a restrained power.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Cooper's Choice The Cooper's Choice
Glen Grant
1977, 27 Years Old, Sherry Cask
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Fascinating, but the oak is having the greater say.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Berry Bros. & Rudd Berry Bros. & Rudd
Berry's Best
Orkney, 14 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A delicious session dram but could do with more oomph.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Duncan Taylor Duncan Taylor
Auld Reekie
'The Big Smoke', Aged 12 Years
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A drinkable, if relatively undemanding whisky. Perhaps a good introduction to Islay.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Glen Moray Glen Moray
Mountain Oak Malt, Distillery Manager's Choice
ABV 60.0%
Comments: A robust rendition. One for mountaineers?
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Cooper's Choice
1976, 27 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Always a complex whisky, hard to pin down. This sample seems to have triggered an oriental mood.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Murray McDavid Mission II Murray McDavid Mission II
Strathisla
1976, Aged 27 Years
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Strathisla is always charming but can be a touch frosty. This is one of those.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Macallan The Macallan
Replica 1876
ABV 40.6%
Comments: A bit young and one-dimensional. Quite disappointing.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Gordon & MacPhail
Port Ellen
1982
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A gentle Port Ellen, with the sea influencing the nose more than the palate. Would have proved a heftier guy at a higher strength.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Royal Brackla
25 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A well built and delicious dram.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Celtique Connexion Celtique Connexion
Speyside 1990, Vin de Paille du Jura Wood Finish
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A new flavour and a valid one. Well handled. Just a little grippy for me.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Auchentoshan Auchentoshan
1973, 29 Years Old
ABV 55.8%
Comments: Has held its own very well for such an allegedly light spirit. Mature and substantial.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Chieftain's Chieftain's
Caol Ila
1990, Aged 12 Years
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A very good, well-balanced Caol Ila, but not enough happening to make it complex. Ideal for beginners.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Macallan
1949, 52 Years Old, Vintage
ABV 41.1%
Comments: Not much evidence of alcohol. Elegant but frail. Doesn't approach the 1948 I tasted a few years ago.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
The Scotch Malt Whisky Society
Caol Ila
53.50 – 7 Years Old
ABV 62.1%
Comments: You can see why blenders adore this. For those who like their Islay malts aggressive, zesty and smoky.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Mortlach
16 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A great malt that is enigmatic and sometimes seems reclusive.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Lombard Lombard
Rosebank
1989
ABV 50.0%
Comments: Ethereal. It seems to fill the mouth with perfume.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Finlaggan
17 Years Old, Islay Malt
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Not as pungent as younger versions, but retains Islay character. Lovely fruit/smoke interplay.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Bowmore Bowmore
Legend
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A well-knitted dram,although suffering from being bottled at 40%.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Adelphi Balmenach
1990, 11 Years Old, Cask 507
ABV 59.7%
Comments: Can whiskies be handsome and romantic? This is a seductive bottling.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Signatory Signatory
The Glenturret
1973
ABV 55.5%
Comments: Brinkmanship at its bravest and best: another summer would have done this one in.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Speyburn Speyburn
21 Years Old
ABV 58.5%
Comments: Full of flavour and interest, but the sherry and oak verge on being overwhelming.
OVERALL SCORE
8.1
Westland Westland
Colere
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Raising the bar for American whiskey.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Cotswolds Cotswolds
Sherry Cask Single Malt Whisky
ABV 57.4%
Comments: A nice, not-quite-sherry-bomb whisky that has plenty of balance between sweetness, the wood and fruits.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Connoisseurs Choice Connoisseurs Choice
Speyburn
Speyburn 1991
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A perfect pre-dinner dram. All that fruit is going to set the taste buds begging for more, please.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The BenRiach The BenRiach
Birnie Moss Intensely Peated
ABV 48.0%
Comments: The potting shed drams continue, perfect for warming the soul on an evening.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Lady of the Glen Lady of the Glen
Glenlossie
8643/2010 Hogshead, Ex Tawny Port
ABV 54.6%
Comments: A good Autumnal whisky with plenty going on. Certainly one for later in the evening and go easy with the water.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Lady of the Glen Lady of the Glen
Glenlossie
8645/2010 Hogshead, Ex Ruby Port
ABV 56.8%
Comments: An interesting and multi-layered whisky, with some lovely fruity edges to it.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Clydebuilt Clydebuilt
Coppersmith
ABV 48.0%
Comments: Pretty easy going and lovely, but a little one dimensional in its delivery.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Single Malts of Scotland The Single Malts of Scotland
Cragganmore
1985, 22 Years Old
ABV 56.7%
Comments: Balanced and calming. Worth a look.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Duncan Taylor Rare Auld Duncan Taylor Rare Auld
Carsebridge
1979, 26 Years Old
ABV 62.3%
Comments: A real character with well integrated elements. Oak speaks up but in a well-educated manner. Can certainly make a solid backbone in an old blend.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Duncan Taylor Rare Auld Duncan Taylor Rare Auld
Glen Moray
1983, 26 Years Old
ABV 55.9%
Comments: Slightly obvious and a bit of a show pony, but not bad.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Duncan Taylor Dimensions Duncan Taylor Dimensions
Mortlach
1989, 23 Years Old
ABV 55.8%
Comments: Classic and just what I would have expected from this distillery as well.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glen Garioch Glen Garioch
Virgin Oak
ABV 48.0%
Comments: It was interesting to see how the virgin wood has softened the big bear up.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Teeling Teeling
Single Grain
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Rather a guilty pleasure.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glenmorangie Glenmorangie
18 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A rich, mouth-filling dram that offers surprising length and depth to the finish.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glenmorangie Glenmorangie
15 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A belter beside last embers of a log fire.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glen Garioch Glen Garioch
Aged 21 Years
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A lovely malt more delicious for its effect than its complexity.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glen Moray
16 Years Old, Chenin Blanc Finish
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Firmer and more assertive.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glenmorangie
12 Years Old, Millennium Malt
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A charming and excellent single malt offering untold complexity in the layers of flavours.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glenfiddich Glenfiddich
15 Years Old, Solera Reserve
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Elegant. Well-balanced to the point of suavity.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Linkwood Linkwood
12 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A classic example of a relatively light and fragrant whisky that has real complexity and a gorgeous feel. The perfect summertime dram.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Auchentoshan Auchentoshan
21 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A fruity rumble in the hay. Oo arr missus.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Yamazaki The Yamazaki
Aged 18 Years
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Strikes an excellent balance between those spicy high tones and a sweet but nutty palate. A little slick.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Ledaig Ledaig
Aged 7 Years
ABV 42.0%
Comments: A cheeky wee monkey. Lively.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glann Ar Mor Glann Ar Mor
2005, 3 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A young but very decent dram. To enjoy on a summer evening.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Tobermory Tobermory
12 Years Old
ABV 46.3%
Comments: A solid, dependable whisky with all in balance.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The GlenDronach The GlenDronach
Cask Strength Batch 7
ABV 57.9%
Comments: An interesting whisky and one for saving for a cold snap.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Shelter Point Shelter Point
Artisanal Cask Strength Whisky
ABV 57.2%
Comments: Packs a serious punch. Once the alcohol is backed a way reveals a stunner.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Lombard Jewels of Scotland Lombard Jewels of Scotland
Glenallachie
Single Cask
ABV 54.9%
Comments: Alcoholic strength is not shown when neat, water helps draw out more layers.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
OMAR OMAR
Cask Strength
ABV 58.2%
Comments: Certainly works on several levels and that smoke note is gorgeous. Brilliant.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Master of Malt Master of Malt
Whisky Liqueur, 15 Years Old
ABV 42.0%
Comments: Interesting aromatic profile and good balance. To be enjoyed on crushed ice with chocolate or vanilla ice cream (or both !!).
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Scotch Malt Whisky Society The Scotch Malt Whisky Society
Glencraig
104.13 – An Angel Fallen to Earth
ABV 50.6%
Comments: Amazing nose. Just loses momemtum a little in the mouth, but worth a look.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
James Eadie James Eadie
Caol Ila
8 YearsOld, Small Batch
ABV 46.0%
Comments: The winds blow Caribbean tropics to Islay.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Langatun Langatun
Winter Wedding
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A great drop for a garden party.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The GlenDronach The GlenDronach
Single Cask Batch 14, Aged 12 Years
ABV 58.3%
Comments: Like a hug in a high-ABV mug (which is the exact-sized receptacle I’d like to enjoy this in).
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glenmorangie Glenmorangie
Dornoch
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A little too short in the finish.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
PUNI PUNI
Alba
ABV 43.0%
Comments: This tastes like it could be a great dram, but not for another few years yet.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Dalmore The Dalmore
21 Years Old
ABV 42.0%
Comments: Lots of flavours which ultimately confuse the drinker. Not a bad dram, just very strange indeed.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Octave The Octave
Glenburgie
2008, Aged 6 Years
ABV 55.7%
Comments: One could be forgiven for thinking that this was a flavoured liqueur, with the intensity of the vanilla and cherry flavours.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Tullibardine Tullibardine
228 Burgundy Finish
ABV 43.0%
Comments: This is certainly a pleasant whisky, but a little uninspiring for me.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Mackmyra Mackmyra
Midvinter
ABV 46.1%
Comments: Very unusual. Almost like a liqueur, but without any of the syrupy sweetness on the palate.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glenmorangie Glenmorangie
Tùsail
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A lovely robust, deep whisky with a delightful finish. What more can you say?
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Old Pulteney Old Pulteney
Navigator
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Whisky in ballet shoes and on tip toes, delightful.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Ballechin Ballechin
10 Years Old, Single Malt
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A reflective dram that needs time to unravel.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
That Boutique-y Whisky Company That Boutique-y Whisky Company
Glen Grant
Batch 1
ABV 50.1%
Comments: A slippery one and difficult to get to grips with, I kept changing my mind.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Armorik Single Malt Armorik Single Malt
Whisky Breton Double Maturation
ABV 46.0%
Comments: This whisky was pulled at the right time; it won't see another World Cup in cask. On the podium, but not quite punchy enough to take gold.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Speciality Drinks Speciality Drinks
Elements of Islay
Lp5 (Laphroaig)
ABV 52.4%
Comments: A refreshing young bourbon matured dram. Not complex but well balanced. It needs water though to get smoother.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Darkness! Darkness!
The Macallan
15 Years Old, PX Cask
ABV 52.3%
Comments: A dry whisky with a sour fruit profile. It lacks balance and body.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glenglassaugh Glenglassaugh
Torfa
ABV 50.0%
Comments: A pleasant dram which needs more years in the cask to give the full measure of its aromatic profile.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
That Boutique-y Whisky Company That Boutique-y Whisky Company
Miltonduff
Batch 1
ABV 51.4%
Comments: Pleasant enough.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Balvenie The Balvenie
Doublewood Aged 17 Years
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Nothing gives away that finish.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Speciality Drinks Speciality Drinks
Elements of Islay
Pl1 (Port Charlotte)
ABV 60.0%
Comments: With water, this shows signs of popping its head over to the other side, but only fleetingly.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Master of Malt Master of Malt
Single Cask Series
Aberlour, 1995, Aged 17 Years
ABV 56.0%
Comments: Alcohol is well mastered and balanced.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
anCnoc anCnoc
Vintage 1998
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A pleasant dram, well balanced and refreshing.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glenfarclas Glenfarclas
Movember 9 Years Old
ABV 46.3%
Comments: Light and well structured. Refreshing.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Mackmyra Mackmyra
Special 02 - The Anniversary Edition
ABV 50.0%
Comments: Perfectly pleasant.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Macallan The Macallan
Estate Reserve
ABV 48.0%
Comments: A surprise for a Macallan - but a pleasant one.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glenkinchie Glenkinchie
1990 20 Years Old
ABV 55.1%
Comments: A lively character. Better than a wake up call.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Glenrothes The Glenrothes
Vintage 1995, 16 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: The palate is sweeter and more open than the nose. Oak mellows on time.
Give it time.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Old Pulteney Old Pulteney
Good Hope WK209
ABV 52.0%
Comments: An outdoor dram which comes back indoors as it opens. For a winter warmer up.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Auchentoshan Auchentoshan
11 Years Old 1999 Bordeaux Cask
ABV 58.0%
Comments: An interesting and invigorating autumn dram which needs water to cut the edges.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Wemyss Malts Wemyss Malts
Single Cask Release
1981, Whispering Smoke
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Perfectly sound but I'd prefer more depth (and that doesn't mean heaviness) for a 30 Years Old.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Malts of Scotland
Laphroaig
1998, 10 Years Old
ABV 55.5%
Comments: The perfect image of the countryside in autumn on a wet chilly morning, with a mixture of fog and smoke hovering over the fields and the woods. Very suggestive.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Boisdale Boisdale
Laphroaig
Islay, Cask No. 2255
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Ordered and enjoyable.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Single Malts of Scotland The Single Malts of Scotland
Aged 15 Years
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Good aperitif whisky. Lulls you into a false sense of security then hits you on the finish.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Dalmore The Dalmore
40 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Reminded me of an Armagnac on the nose, then drew me to bourbon lands. The palate is not as rich as the nose. But nothing unpleasant.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Whisky Fair The Whisky Fair
Springbank
1971, 35 Years Old, Sherry Wood
ABV 59.0%
Comments: A gentle,soft candy whisky with no blemishes.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Whisky Fair The Whisky Fair
Longmorn
1976, 31 Years Old
ABV 54.3%
Comments: Better than the 16 Year Old but not a classic.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Old Ballantruan Old Ballantruan
The Peated Malt, Glenlivet
ABV 50.0%
Comments: A number of surprising, and perhaps contradictory, characteristics that actually come together quite nicely in the end.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Rare Malts Selection
Teaninich
1972, Aged 27 Years
ABV 64.2%
Comments: This little-known malt almost always surprises me with its robust flavours.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection
Imperial
1990, Claret Finish
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A superb offering. Just wish G and M would be braver and go with a 43 or 46 rather than the standard 40.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Gordon & MacPhail Gordon & MacPhail
Benromach
1974
ABV 40.0%
Comments: I have always found Benromach assertively flowery, herbal, almost cedary. Will this highly distinctive character prevail in the new, smaller, stills introduced since the change of ownership? Tastings on a recent visit suggest that it might.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Adelphi Adelphi
Rosebank
1992, 9 Years Old
ABV 61.0%
Comments: The aroma promised much, but the palate is curiously drying. Rosebank was never peaty, and this is too young to be woody, so I don't know the origin of that harshness.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Berrys' Own Selection
Dailuaine
1985
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A good example of a little seen distillery.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Ichiro's Malt Ichiro's Malt
Two of Clubs
ABV 57.0%
Comments: The nose is more appealing than the palate. Water tames it.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Benromach Benromach
Sassicaia Wood Finish
ABV 45.0%
Comments: A success.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Old Malt Cask Old Malt Cask
Ardbeg
Aged 15 Years
ABV 50.0%
Comments: Too chimney-like for me. Lacks the balance between sweetness and dryness you need in such a peaty dram.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Aberlour
1994
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A lovely very summery aperitif.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Ian Macleod Ian Macleod
Dun Bheagan
Lowland, Aged 8 Years
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A pretty face with muddy feet.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Dewar Rattray Dewar Rattray
Glen Grant
1985, 19 Years Old
ABV 58.4%
Comments: A definite sharpness which hides a sweeter character. Water does not help much, enhancing the pepperiness. For those who like it hot.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Adelphi Adelphi
Clynelish
1995, 10 Years Old, Cask 12783
ABV 59.3%
Comments: This delivers on palate rather than nose. Oak is just a little hard though.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Bunnahabhain Bunnahabhain
25 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: The nose lets you expect sweeter notes. The palate is a bit disappointing.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Dalmore
1991, Madeira Finish
ABV 60.0%
Comments: Like a passionate rendez-vous between a chocolatier and a distiller.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Auchentoshan Auchentoshan
Aged 17 Years, Bordeaux Wine Finish
ABV 51.0%
Comments: A dram that combines disciplined flavours with delightful variations on a theme.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Glen Grant
1972
ABV 51.0%
Comments: A well matured and well balanced malt. The sherry notes tend to muzzle the distillery character. An iron hand in a velvet glove!
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Cadenhead's Authentic Collection Cadenhead's Authentic Collection
Benromach
1976, Aged 27 Years
ABV 57.1%
Comments: The nose promised more smoothness. Quite an austere character on the palate but with a lot of class.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glen Moray Glen Moray
Aged 16 Years
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Not quite as complex as the previous 16 Years Old, but delicious.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Douglas Laing Old & Rare Platinum Selection
The Macallan
1977, Aged 27 Years
ABV 51.0%
Comments: Good balance, but not the weight or maturity you want from such an old malt.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Macallan The Macallan
10 Years Old, Fine Oak
ABV 0.0%
Comments: Best neat. Clean, crisp attack.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Dewar Rattray Cask Collection Dewar Rattray Cask Collection
Dufftown
1975, 29 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Interesting, but without the overriding character to make it great.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Douglas Laing
Bladnoch
1977, 22 Years Old
ABV 50.0%
Comments: Good balance of the fruity acidity and sweeter juicy notes.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Glenrothes
1989
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A very elegant, superbly balanced middle-weight dram.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Gordon & MacPhail Gordon & MacPhail
Caol Ila
1990
ABV 58.2%
Comments: A very good introduction to Caol Ila.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Scotch Malt Whisky Society
Bunnahabhain
10.56 – 6 Years Old
ABV 59.4%
Comments: I admired its feistiness, but I might be more comfortable with a greater degree of maturity.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Hakushu
1984 White Oak Cask
ABV 61.0%
Comments: Its edgy assertiveness might bother aesthetes but I warm to a whisky that knows its own mind.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Gordon & MacPhail
Strathisla
1960
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A rich expression of a venerable sherry maturation. Will delight sherry-cask aficionados.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Celtique Connexion Celtique Connexion
Speyside 1989, Armagnac Wood Finish
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Still sweet, but much more rounded. Real depth of flavour, tastes more like Armagnac than whisky. I would like to try it with pecan pie.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Macallan
1948 Select Reserve
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Paler in colour and lighter in body, but what a palate...great Speyside whiskies once tasted like this.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Macallan
1945, 56 Years Old, Vintage
ABV 51.5%
Comments: More of a spicy tendency than other versions.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Signatory Signatory
Caol Ila
1991, Port Wood
ABV 46.0%
Comments: I would like to try this with lamb.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Murray McDavid Murray McDavid
Rosebank
1990, 8 Years Old, Sherry Cask
ABV 40.0%
Comments: The flowery youth of the whisky and the freshness of the sherry cask achieve an interesting harmony.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Isle of Jura Isle of Jura
Aged 21 Years
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Jura needs time to open and this is a good example.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Hart Brothers Hart Brothers
Highland Park
25 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A pretty phenolic example. Lacks the complexity and harmony of the Adelphi bottling.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Gordon & MacPhail Gordon & MacPhail
The Glenlivet
1973, Cask Strength
ABV 55.9%
Comments: Surprisingly vibrant for its age. There is a gap between the sharp nose and soothingly smooth palate. Water reconciles both. Would go well with a pear and almond pie.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Connoisseur's Choice Connoisseur's Choice
Rosebank
1988
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A deft balance between the whisky's own character and the sherry.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Glenlivet
1968 Vintage
ABV 52.8%
Comments: Excellent character, though the oak has taken a firmer grip than on the 1967; this is never quite so rich.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Highland Park Highland Park
1958
ABV 44.0%
Comments: Some drinkers might perfer this great whisky slightly younger and fresher. Those who like a touch of oak will find this very elegant.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Rare Malts Selection Rare Malts Selection
Dufftown-Glenlivet, 1975, 21 Years Old
ABV 54.8%
Comments: Brilliant balance of barley sweetness and spice. A joy.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Rare Malts Selection
Glen Ord
1974, 23 Years Old
ABV 60.8%
Comments: Extremely high quality expression from an ill-served distillery.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Murray McDavid
Caol Ila
1989
ABV 62.7%
Comments: On the light side, but with some delicacy and complexity.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Adelphi Port Ellen
1975, 24 Years Old
ABV 59.0%
Comments: Seems to have faded slightly with age.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glenmorangie Glenmorangie
Original
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A gentle dram,lively and refreshing. To toast the spring.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glenfiddich Glenfiddich
Havana Reserve, 21 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Good balance with the rum at no point overwhelming the whisky. American readers will have to smuggle it into the country along with their Cohibas.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Old Pulteney
15 Years Old, Sherry Cask
ABV 40.0%
Comments: A genuinely delightful malt that shows great charisma beyond the so-so nose.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Cadenhead's Cadenhead's
Lochside
1981, Aged 19 Years
ABV 60.9%
Comments: This was never a great distillery but it made some perfectly pleasant whiskies and its loss is to be regretted. This bottling is past its best but obviously has rarity value.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glenfarclas Glenfarclas
Aged 15 Years
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Classic sherry, well balanced. A perfect companion for a creamy pud.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glenfiddich Glenfiddich
30 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Another where the nose promises a lot, but the palate doesn't quite deliver.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Bruichladdich Bruichladdich
10 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Laddie reaches 10 in good shape.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Aberfeldy Aberfeldy
Aged 12 Years
ABV 40.0%
Comments: Refreshing and light-hearted. Almost too playful to take seriously.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Bimber Bimber
Oloroso Cask Small Batch 003
ABV 51.4%
Comments: Lovely use of sherry here creates a moreish drop.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Gordon & MacPhail Gordon & MacPhail
St. Magdalene
1975, 30 Years Old
ABV 53.0%
Comments: A complete curveball from nose to palate. Certainly different and one to look out for and try.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Single Malts of Scotland The Single Malts of Scotland
Macduff
1991, 17 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: It’s trying so hard to be the life and soul of the party, but hasn’t the personality to do so.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Chieftain's Chieftain's
Benrinnes
10 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Difficult to sense the sauternes cask influence. Maybe some added sweetness but the aromas are not precise. A pleasant dram though.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Speciality Drinks Speciality Drinks
Port Askaig
17 Years Old
ABV 45.8%
Comments: Balanced and clean.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Cadenhead's Duthies Cadenhead's Duthies
Mortlach
16 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Attractive and worth a look.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Master of Malt Master of Malt
The Arran Malt
1996, 12 Years Old
ABV 54.7%
Comments: An enticing combination of pudding-like flavours and crisp texture.Sweet but not cloying at all.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Duncan Taylor Rare Auld Duncan Taylor Rare Auld
Glen Moray
1987, 23 Years Old
ABV 54.4%
Comments: After a strangely flat start it builds in energy but somehow just lacks definition. Very pleasant though.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Auchentoshan Auchentoshan
Virgin Oak
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Almost the perfect breakfast in a glass really.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Master of Malt Master of Malt
Glentauchers
1997, 15 Years Old
ABV 53.0%
Comments: A delicate dram, certainly one for the summer.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Tomatin Tomatin
2009 Rum Finish
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Sweet all the way and not much else, but very enjoyable for what it offers.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Teaninich Teaninich
Aged 17 Years, Special Release
ABV 55.9%
Comments: Nice enough, but it’s hard to feel too excited about this.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Casino Series Casino Series
Islay Cask #Blackjack, Aged 21 Years
ABV 50.4%
Comments: A must for visiting the Scottish islands. Balanced with great spices.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Port Charlotte Port Charlotte
2007 CC: 01
ABV 57.8%
Comments: If that doesn’t put a rocket up you, what will?!
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Highland Park Highland Park
Fire Edition, Aged 15 Years
ABV 45.2%
Comments: The nose is a little peculiar at first, but the solid flavours put those doubts to rest.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Wemyss Malts Wemyss Malts
Bunnahabhain
1988, Kirsch Gâteau
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Like ‘high def eyebrows’, for me this is overdone, but for others it might be the most attractive thing around.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Van Brunt Stillhouse Van Brunt Stillhouse
Lot #7 Small Batch
ABV 42.0%
Comments: Due to its youth, this dram is a work in progress.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Machrie Morr Machrie Morr
Cask Strength
ABV 58.4%
Comments: Very pungent. A tired cask? Water cuts the edges a bit but there is still this burning sensation.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Abbey Whisky Abbey Whisky
Glencadam
22 Years Old
ABV 55.3%
Comments: A delicate whisky but the alcohol bite makes it difficult to fully appreciate.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Darkness! Darkness!
Benrinnes
15 Years Old, PX Cask
ABV 53.3%
Comments: There is a theme running in these samples. Huge merits, but the tannic note takes the edge off slightly.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Slyrs Slyrs
Sherry Edition No.1
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Not a huge fan of the nose, it must be said, but the more time you let this to develop, the goods are definitely delivered.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Paul John Paul John
Edited
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Solid enough, with a nice peaty backbone to it.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Kilchoman Kilchoman
Machir Bay Release
ABV 46.0%
Comments: You'll be in seventh heaven if a deep bog floats your boat.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glen Garioch Glen Garioch
(A Rare Find) 1986, 26 Years Old, Cask No. 1807
ABV 52.4%
Comments: A really well put together whisky, well integrated and balanced.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Berry Bros. & Rudd Berry Bros. & Rudd
1991, 21 Years Old
ABV 54.8%
Comments: A pleasant dram. A touch of water brings out a refined oak frame and beeswax. A kind of spicy fruit salad.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Berry Bros. & Rudd Berry Bros. & Rudd
Mortlach
1998, 14 Years Old
ABV 57.5%
Comments: A pleasant light aromatic profile but this whisky has not matured in very active casks.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Auchroisk
1991, 20 Years Old
ABV 54.6%
Comments: A lovely dram for a sunny winter's day.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Yamazaki The Yamazaki
Puncheon
ABV 48.0%
Comments: A decent well put together whisky.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Duncan Taylor Dimensions Duncan Taylor Dimensions
Strathmill
1990, Aged 21 Years
ABV 55.0%
Comments: A very dry dram, with some interesting fruity moments.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Springbank Springbank
18 Years Old
ABV 46.0%
Comments: A decent dram. Nose and palate are miles apart but why not ? We could
have expected more complexity.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Miyagikyo Miyagikyo
1990, 19 Years Old
ABV 61.0%
Comments: Funny enough,that strong dram is better neat. But give it time.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Speciality Drinks Speciality Drinks
Elements of Islay
Cl1 (Caol Ila)
ABV 62.9%
Comments: Young, vibrant and brimful of personality.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Montgomerie's Montgomerie's
Rosebank
1990
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Another which shows that light doesn't mean insubstantial.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Longrow Longrow
Gaja Barolo
ABV 55.8%
Comments: The unusual cask provides a different take to the previous malt - but not an unwelcome one.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glenmorangie Glenmorangie
Lasanta
ABV 46.0%
Comments: Very well integrated. A real improvement.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Macallan The Macallan
Gran Reserva
ABV 45.6%
Comments: Good balance of high-impact oak and rich spirit. A powerful Macallan.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Three Ships Three Ships
Aged 10 Years
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A decent malt. Well balanced.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Speciality Drinks Speciality Drinks
Port Askaig
Cask Strength
ABV 57.1%
Comments: Good presence.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Berrys' Own Selection Berrys' Own Selection
Ledaig
2005, 5 Years Old
ABV 62.7%
Comments: This hits the palate like an angry drunken fisherman swaggering into Tobermory’s Mishnish Hotel. Uncompromising and rather impressive.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Bowmore
The Devil’s Casks, 10 Years Old
ABV 56.9%
Comments: An odd, but pleasing dram.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
That Boutique-y Whisky Company That Boutique-y Whisky Company
Glen Keith
Batch 2
ABV 44.0%
Comments: Lacking some cohesion. Enjoyable though.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Ben Nevis Ben Nevis
10 Years Old, Batch 1
ABV 62.4%
Comments: An exciting dram with lots of punch.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection
Longmorn
1961, European Oak
ABV 45.0%
Comments: Takes you through a whole raft of flavours and aromas as you move from nose to palate.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Green Spot Green Spot
Chateau Montelena
ABV 46.0%
Comments: This is not complex, but it’s a charming everyday dram.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Notch The Notch
12 Years Old Batch No 2
ABV 48.0%
Comments: Easy-going, pleasant to drink but not particularly memorable.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Wemyss Malts Wemyss Malts
Bunnahabhain
1990, East Neuk Dunes
ABV 46.0%
Comments: The oak hasn’t fully removed the unwanted impurities, but left any longer the oak would have probably overwhelmed the palate.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Nant Nant
Sherry Wood Single Cask
ABV 43.0%
Comments: A great start but let down a little by the back palate and the overly dry finish.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Edradour Straight from the Cask Edradour Straight from the Cask
Port Wood Finish 13 Years Old
ABV 56.3%
Comments: The alcohol is quite overwhelming. Works best with water. But even so, it lacks a little in structure and richness.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Speciality Drinks Speciality Drinks
Elements of Islay
Ar4 (Ardbeg)
ABV 58.1%
Comments: A strong phenolic profile framed in solid oak. The alcohol is not totally mastered. Adding water brings out bitterness.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Singleton of Glen Ord The Singleton of Glen Ord
Trinité
ABV 44.0%
Comments: A well balanced dram.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Mackmyra Mackmyra
Svensk Rok
ABV 48.1%
Comments: So familiar and so lovely. A sympohony of smoke and peat.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Master of Malt Master of Malt
Tormore, 28 Years Old
ABV 60.2%
Comments: Interesting whisky but the high ABV requires some precautions. Time, a dash of water and you have an energetic and talkative dram!
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Glen Garioch Glen Garioch
1995
ABV 55.3%
Comments: Balanced and well layered, just need a drop of water to help it emerge.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Sullivans Cove Sullivans Cove
American Oak 11 Years Old
ABV 47.5%
Comments: For maximum impact have neat.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Bruichladdich Bruichladdich
Octomore Comus 4.2 2007
ABV 61.0%
Comments: Difficult to enjoy without water. Water enhances the smokiness and releases a sooty note. Ne plus ultra for the peat freaks out there.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Scott's Selection
Dailuaine
1983, 28 Years Old
ABV 55.8%
Comments: Marked down slightly for an undistinguished nose.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Tomintoul Tomintoul
1976, 33 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Holds up very well for a whisky a third of a century old.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Yoichi Yoichi
1991, 18 Years Old
ABV 58.0%
Comments: A warm but rich character. Water tames it a little. Some like it hot !
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Kornog Kornog
Taouarc'H Kentan 2006 3 Years Old
ABV 57.1%
Comments: The profile of a well knitted young islander. Of the gentle sort. Alcohol is well mastered. Invigorating and cuddling at the same time.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Balblair Balblair
2000
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Quite a shy whisky but elegant and well knitted. Avoid water though.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Teerenpeli Teerenpeli
8 Years Old
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Very well made. Finland emerges as a whisky nation.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Hazelburn Hazelburn
Sauternes
ABV 55.9%
Comments: An unusual aromatic display. To try when you feel different? Maybe. That perfume profile made my tastebuds uncomfortable though.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Dewar Rattray Cask Collection Dewar Rattray Cask Collection
Glen Mhor
1982, 27 Years Old
ABV 54.2%
Comments: An assertive character. A complex nose, a less enticing palate though. But water cuts the edge and makes it conversational. Needs time to 'relax'
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
The Cask of Yamazaki The Cask of Yamazaki
1993, Heavily Peated Malt
ABV 62.0%
Comments: A wonderful exercise in smoke,but with great depth.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Macleod's Macleod's
Islay Single Malt, 8 Years Old
ABV 40.0%
Comments: An unreconstructed alpha male.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
Ian Macleod Ian Macleod
Dun Bheagan
Island, Aged 8 Years
ABV 43.0%
Comments: Plays a bit rough and ready, but still quite likeable.
OVERALL SCORE
8.0
|
