Lagavulin 

16 Years Old

ABV 43.0%

Comments: A true classic in every sense that offers breathtaking depth.

OVERALL SCORE

9.6

 Tullibardine  Tullibardine 

1970

ABV 40.5%

Comments: Pretty much how mainland Scotch whisky should taste (holds breath for price).

OVERALL SCORE

9.6

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

1948, 51 Years Old

ABV 46.6%

Comments: Drink it and travel back in time. It is one of the finest malts I have ever tasted.

OVERALL SCORE

9.6

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

1949, 50 Years Old, Millennium

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A beautifully composed, luxurious whisky.

OVERALL SCORE

9.6

 Corsair  Corsair 

Triple Smoke Single Barrel Distiller Select

ABV 67.5%

Comments: It’s a love or hate whisky and I love it.

OVERALL SCORE

9.5

 Glenfiddich  Glenfiddich 

12 Years Old

ABV 40.0%

Comments: 40%? Really? Packs a punch with a ton of flavour.

OVERALL SCORE

9.5

 Corsair  Corsair 

Triple Smoke, Single Barrel

ABV 67.5%

Comments: It’s a love or hate whisky and I love it.

OVERALL SCORE

9.5

 Lagavulin  Lagavulin 

1980, The Distillers Edition, Pedro Ximenez Finish

ABV 43.0%

Comments: A more lingering, classic Lagavulin with some of the corners knocked off and some subtle depths added.

OVERALL SCORE

9.5

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

1979, 18 Years Old, Gran Reserva

ABV 40.0%

Comments: A formidable dram with enough about it to scrum down with any heavyweight.

OVERALL SCORE

9.5

 Ardbeg  Ardbeg 

10 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: comm

OVERALL SCORE

9.5

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

Special Reserve

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Classic example of The Macallan.

OVERALL SCORE

9.4

 Highland Park  Highland Park 

1977, Bicentenary Vintage Reserve

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Distilled during one of the best periods in HP's recent history. If only they had bottled at 46!! One of all time greats, for all that.

OVERALL SCORE

9.4

  Ardbeg 

Provenance, 1974, 24 Years Old

ABV 55.6%

Comments: Rich and creamy, with huge flavour development.

OVERALL SCORE

9.4

 The Scotch Malt Whisky Society  The Scotch Malt Whisky Society 

114.1 – Millennium Malt, 9 Years Old

ABV 58.1%

Comments: A cask well worth keeping back to see in the new century. And, as a 9 Years Old, proves that youth can conquer over age. Spectacular.

OVERALL SCORE

9.4

 Lombard Jewels of Scotland  Lombard Jewels of Scotland 

Brora 

1982, Cask No. 876

ABV 46.1%

Comments: Just fantastic. Smoke, heather and fruits combine to produce pre-?war style product.

OVERALL SCORE

9.4

 Paul John  Paul John 

Select Cask Peated

ABV 55.5%

Comments: I can’t wait to make a Blood and Sand with this, or drink with a touch of water.

OVERALL SCORE

9.4

 Wemyss Malts  Wemyss Malts 

Bunnahabhain 

An Antique Armchair

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A stunner of an Islay whisky, great balance of sweet fruits, smoke and wood notes. Send case please.

OVERALL SCORE

9.4

 Lombard Jewels of Scotland  Lombard Jewels of Scotland 

Glenury Royal 1973 Cask #6867

ABV 50.0%

Comments: Classic style whisky. If you want to know why, buy and try.

OVERALL SCORE

9.4

 Balcones  Balcones 

Lineage

ABV 47.0%

Comments: A fantastic sip that has some hidden depths behind the shyness.

OVERALL SCORE

9.3

 Highland Park  Highland Park 

1970 Vintage

ABV 48.0%

Comments: An incredible buoyancy and vitality for its age. You think of Dylan's song Forever Young. Fantastic!

OVERALL SCORE

9.3

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

50 Years Old, Millennium Decanter

ABV 43.0%

Comments: A classic example of well-aged Spanish.

OVERALL SCORE

9.3

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

1946, 52 Years Old

ABV 43.0%

Comments: A very unusual expression of The Macallan. Unquestionably a classic.

OVERALL SCORE

9.3

 Talisker  Talisker 

10 Years Old

ABV 45.8%

Comments: Always a classic, though I still miss the 8 Years Old.

OVERALL SCORE

9.3

 Glenfarclas  Glenfarclas 

1953, 58 Years

ABV 47.2%

Comments: Quite magnificent.

OVERALL SCORE

9.3

 Three Ships  Three Ships 

10 Years Old Limited Edition

ABV 44.6%

Comments: Normally I would complain about the palate not displaying the exuberance of the nose, but I can’t moan at all about the depth and quality!

OVERALL SCORE

9.3

 Lombard  Lombard 

Springbank 

1965

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Brilliant with one weakness… the weakness; I wish it was a slightly higher ABV.

OVERALL SCORE

9.3

 Glencadam  Glencadam 

19 Years Old Oloroso Sherry Cask Finish

ABV 46.0%

Comments: An old-school style of single malt where oak flavours mattered.

OVERALL SCORE

9.3

 Highland Park  Highland Park 

40 Years Old

ABV 48.3%

Comments: What a beauty! Flavours beaming,oak at peace... Complexity meets elegancy.

OVERALL SCORE

9.3

 Bowmore  Bowmore 

1968, Aged 37 Years

ABV 43.4%

Comments: Head and shoulders above the others in this batch.

OVERALL SCORE

9.3

  The Macallan 

1961 Vintage

ABV 54.7%

Comments: Fascinating. A very different style of Macallan. If you buy for your unopened collection, get a miniature as well so you can at least try it.

OVERALL SCORE

9.3

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

Replica 1874

ABV 45.0%

Comments: A deft re-creation. This version is notably estery.

OVERALL SCORE

9.3

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

18 Years Old

ABV 40.0%

Comments: A lovely whisky in its own right, but not quite as layered as the best vintages.

OVERALL SCORE

9.3

 Highland Park  Highland Park 

18 Years Old

ABV 43.0%

Comments: If I smoked I would have a cigar with this one.

OVERALL SCORE

9.3

  Ardbeg 

1976, Distillery Manager's Choice

ABV 56.0%

Comments: Real Ardbeg peatiness and smokiness.

OVERALL SCORE

9.3

  Lagavulin 

1979 Distillers Edition, Pedro Ximenez Finish

ABV 43.0%

Comments: A big improvement on the first version with much more fruit, body and intensity. Beautiful.

OVERALL SCORE

9.3

 Abbey Whisky  Abbey Whisky 

Glenallachie 

10 Years Old, 2008, AW Exclusive

ABV 66.2%

Comments: What a stunner. Everything seems to be knit together nicely with great depth and balance. 66.2%? Really?

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 The Cardrona Distillery  The Cardrona Distillery 

Just Hatched Solera

ABV 64.4%

Comments: Stunning, doesn’t give its ABV away until right at the end. Well structured and balanced. Send a case immediately (joking of course, honestly).

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 Ailsa Bay  Ailsa Bay 

Sweet Smoke

ABV 48.9%

Comments: A wonderful example of smoke and sweetness together in near perfection.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 Casino Series  Casino Series 

Rum Cask #Poker, Aged 21 Years

ABV 47.6%

Comments: Gorgeous and breathtaking, that play of the seaside and earthiness, perfect balance.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 Wemyss Malts  Wemyss Malts 

Bowmore 

1990, Briny Tangle

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A lovely dram with enough youthful spirit, oak influence and peat to please most.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 Benromach  Benromach 

35 Years Old

ABV 43.0%

Comments: What a well-balanced whisky, full of flavour and poise.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 Cragganmore  Cragganmore 

25 Years Old

ABV 51.4%

Comments: A little over-sweet in places. Aside from that, just wonderful.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 Talisker  Talisker 

Neist Point

ABV 45.8%

Comments: A really well crafted whisky, at a strength that works and a flavour balance that is lovely.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 Glasgow Distillery Company  Glasgow Distillery Company 

Prometheus 

26 Years Old

ABV 47.0%

Comments: A nice dram that delivers well in all areas with some real age and fruity notes to it.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 Mackmyra  Mackmyra 

Brukswhisky

ABV 41.4%

Comments: Rich and deep, really lovely and shows the strength of whisky coming out of Sweden at the moment.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 The Balvenie  The Balvenie 

1972 Vintage Cask

ABV 47.3%

Comments: Proof, if it were needed, that this is a first-growth distillery.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 Balblair  Balblair 

Aged 38 Years, Limited Edition

ABV 44.0%

Comments: A pure beauty. Absolutely beaming on nose and palate. The best a sherry cask can offer.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 Paul John  Paul John 

Select Cask Classic

ABV 55.2%

Comments: Needs a little more interest in the maturation side. Good quality spirit however.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 Tomatin  Tomatin 

36 Years Old Batch 1

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A really lovely whisky which isn’t going to break new ground but at the right price point could be a staple of many people’s cabinets.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 Aultmore  Aultmore 

25 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Evokes a summer-time feel, with plenty of fresh fruits (pineapples, mostly), cream and honey, but I’d be happy to be served a dram of this anytime of year.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 Talisker  Talisker 

Aged 18 Years

ABV 45.8%

Comments: Loch Harport on a winter's day, gale force eight! Less peppery than younger versions. Complex, endearing, balanced. 18 seems a perfect age for malts.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

1981, Unfiltered Cask Strength

ABV 57.0%

Comments: This is simplified summary of a breathlessly complex Macallan. Their finest bottling in years. Magnificent.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

  Glenfiddich 

40 Years Old

ABV 43.6%

Comments: Anyone who reckons Glenfiddich is not a top-rate distillery should sample this.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

Thirties

ABV 40.0%

Comments: The dry amontillado.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

  The Balvenie 

1970 Vintage Cask

ABV 44.6%

Comments: Complex, luscious, gorgeous.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

  Ardbeg 

1977

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A stunner.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 Adelphi  Adelphi 

Highland Park 

17 Years Old, Cask 2903

ABV 55.3%

Comments: That dance might have been led by Fred Astaire. The great all-rounder in lean and energetic mood. Makes it look easy. Try it with a late-night movie.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 The Balvenie  The Balvenie 

The week of peat 14 Years Old

ABV 43.3%

Comments: Lovely balance and interplay between the smoke and the sweetness.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 The Balvenie  The Balvenie 

A day of dark barley 26 Years Old

ABV 47.8%

Comments: A gentle drop that packs a punch towards the end. A velvet covered hand in a velvet glove.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 Caol Ila  Caol Ila 

35 Years Old, 2018 Special Releases

ABV 58.1%

Comments: A complex whisky that takes you on a ride from saline to sweetness, via smoke.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 Wemyss Malts  Wemyss Malts 

Caol Ila 

1980, The Admiral’s Beacon

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A wonderful whisky which does Islay, and Scotland, proud. Could become a classic.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 Connoisseurs Choice  Connoisseurs Choice 

Glen Elgin 

1998, Aged 17 Years

ABV 46.0%

Comments: There are elements of this which evoke vintage malts of yesteryear, however slightly bitter undertones let down the balance of this whisky.

OVERALL SCORE

9.2

 The Lakes  The Lakes 

Whiskymaker's Reserve No.1

ABV 60.6%

Comments: The full gamut of aroma and flavour. Well balanced and put together.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Glenfarclas  Glenfarclas 

21 Years Old

ABV 43.0%

Comments: If Bertie Basset made whisky, awesome stuff.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Smögen Svensk  Smögen Svensk 

Sherry Project 1:4

ABV 57.2%

Comments: A really lovely whisky in the new world style.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Master of Malt  Master of Malt 

Speyside 60 Years Old

ABV 42.2%

Comments: A rich, complex spicy whisky with perfectly integrated oak. To be savored slowly and preferably neat.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 The Whisky Exchange  The Whisky Exchange 

Linkwood 

Aged 16 Years, Sherry Cask Retro Label

ABV 48.1%

Comments: This is a wonderful bottling. It has the suave and brooding character of Mr Fox in Jemima Puddleduck.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 The BenRiach  The BenRiach 

16 Years Old, Sauternes Finish

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A wonderful dram, retaining the fruity and almondy notes of the sauternes.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Glenfarclas  Glenfarclas 

25 Years Old

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Initially shy, but then opens up with glorious results.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 A. D. Rattray  A. D. Rattray 

Cask Orkney 

18 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: One for an evening stroll on the beach, preferably with a storm brewing.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Craigellachie  Craigellachie 

33 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Marvellously balanced whisky. Fresh flavours, expressed fabulously. Top dram.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Kilkerran  Kilkerran 

Aged 12 Years

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Everything that is great about Campbeltown. Curious and flavour-bending!

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Darkness!  Darkness! 

Darkness! 

16 Years Old

ABV 54.9%

Comments: This is a wonderful cask selection for a smoky, meaty, oily dram with real oak influence on it.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Master of Malt  Master of Malt 

Paul John, 6 Years Old

ABV 59.7%

Comments: A direct and robust whisky, but it is no joker. Much more Ali than Tyson Fury. Pair with a cold bottle of beer to tame.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Laphroaig  Laphroaig 

15 Years Old

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Excellent smoky whisky making, soft and delicate yet broad shoulders, punchy.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 The Balvenie  The Balvenie 

Tun 1401, Batch 8

ABV 50.2%

Comments: Such poise and grace.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Glenfarclas  Glenfarclas 

43 Years Old, Cognac Cask

ABV 46.7%

Comments: For me best neat. A must-have.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Brora  Brora 

32 Years Old

ABV 54.7%

Comments: If this is the last release, as is rumoured, what a way to go.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Teeling  Teeling 

Blackpitts Peated Single Malt

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Initially this is like hugging a wet dog from the sea, but is nicely balanced with this fruity, sweet side too. Great stuff.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Bruichladdich  Bruichladdich 

Port Charlotte MRC:01

ABV 56.3%

Comments: The promises of long, warm Autumn evenings to come in a glass.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Macallan  Macallan 

30 Years Old, 1989 Vintage Ex Sherry Cask

ABV 44.1%

Comments: Hello sherry bomb… they seem so few and far between these days, especially of this calibre.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Mars Shinshu Distillery  Mars Shinshu Distillery 

Single Cask Komagatake 27 Years Old

ABV 58.0%

Comments: Seriously impressive stuff, one to silence a tasting crowd with. Does not need much water, if any despite the ABV. Just send a case please.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Jura  Jura 

Tastival 2016

ABV 51.0%

Comments: The polar opposite of a big, heavy sherry dram, but equally as appealing.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Box  Box 

The 2nd Step Collection 01

ABV 51.1%

Comments: A really lovely summer drinking whisky, let down a little by the bitter finish.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Ben Nevis  Ben Nevis 

Mr Taketsuru’s Cask 25 Years Old

ABV 61.3%

Comments: The perfect whisky for a nuclear Blood and Sand? Cordial for adults.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Hyde  Hyde 

10 Years Old, Sherry Finish

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A classic, full-bodied Irish malt.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 The Glenturret  The Glenturret 

28 Years Old

ABV 46.5%

Comments: Exceptional whisky making and a brilliant example of what time and oak can do.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Colkegan  Colkegan 

Single Malt Whiskey

ABV 46.0%

Comments: I love this, sign me up please!

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Lagavulin  Lagavulin 

Limited Edition 2010

ABV 52.5%

Comments: If you're a sucker for rich fruity peated whisky this won't disappoint you.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 The Single Malts of Scotland  The Single Malts of Scotland 

The BenRiach 

Aged 21 Years

ABV 56.7%

Comments: Complex with excellent balance. A typical for a Speyside, but it's one hell of a dram!

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Talisker  Talisker 

1982, 20 Years Old

ABV 58.8%

Comments: As subtle a Talisker as you'll come across.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 The Scotch Malt Whisky Society  The Scotch Malt Whisky Society 

Highland Park 

4.73 – 1970

ABV 52.5%

Comments: Not as sophisticated as the distillery bottlings, but robustly salty, earthy and peaty. Good characteristics, but in this bottling they mask the maltiness and sherry character. I wonder whether all island whiskies once tasted like this?

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

1977, 25 Years Old, Christopher's Queen's Jubilee Magnum

ABV 45.5%

Comments: Its wood smoke is the richest and easiest character to recognise.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Yoichi  Yoichi 

10 Years Old, Single Cask

ABV 59.9%

Comments: A terrific whisky, beautifully rounded, with lots of everything.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 Glenfarclas  Glenfarclas 

40 Years Old, Millennium Edition

ABV 43.0%

Comments: An almost immaculate portrayal of an old-fashioned, high quality malt. Quite outstanding for its age.

OVERALL SCORE

9.1

 The Glendronach  The Glendronach 

Virgin Oak Finish 14 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Deep and rich, and well worth taking your time over. Would almost say sumptuous too.

OVERALL SCORE

 

Ballechin 

#8 Sauternes Cask Matured

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Wonderful movement here from the sweetness to drying smoke. Reminds me of a leaf-laden bonfire.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Paul John  Paul John 

Oloroso, Single Malt Whisky

ABV 48.0%

Comments: Nicely put together and the aging has been well handled, all in balance and perfect harmony.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Bunnahabhain  Bunnahabhain 

18 Years Old

ABV 46.3%

Comments: Now this would be interesting as a base for a smoky Tommy’s Margarita and that is a very good thing.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Glenmorangie  Glenmorangie 

Nectar D'or

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Slow to bloom. But so rewarding once opened. Elegant, delicate, and characterful. The sauternes has enriched it with more citrus and dried fruit. A delight.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

  Berrys' Own Selection 

Glenlossie 

1975, 35 Years Old

ABV 49.8%

Comments: Superb balance and complexity.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 House Greyjoy  House Greyjoy 

Talisker Select Reserve

ABV 45.8%

Comments: Simply lovely, one to open and take all night to savour.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Highland Park  Highland Park 

1977, Bicentenary Vintage Reserve

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A rugged expression that lacks the usual complexity but makes up for it with depth and length. A beauty.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

  Redbreast 

Aged 12 Years

ABV 40.0%

Comments: Delicious, soothing, contemplative. A great whiskey. Makes me want to get on a plane to Dublin immediately.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 The Balvenie  The Balvenie 

12 Years Old, Double Wood

ABV 43.0%

Comments: A more intense malt than the Founder's Reserve. Despite its finesse, it is just shaded in regard to all-round complexity. Still nothing short of glorious.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 The BenRiach  The BenRiach 

Batch 16 Cask 7881 Rioja

ABV 53.1%

Comments: Could be an interesting base for a whisky-led Bloody Mary. Great stuff and well balanced.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Hinch  Hinch 

Peated Single Malt

ABV 43.0%

Comments: 43%? Really? Those chilli spices make everything feel much stronger. Punchy and mouth tingling. Different.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Lagavulin  Lagavulin 

12 Years Old

ABV 56.1%

Comments: Complex, sophisticated heavyweight. The one they all have to beat.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

Quest Collection Quest

ABV 40.0%

Comments: Magnificent, a rip-roaring whisky giving great pleasure.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 The Glenrothes  The Glenrothes 

18 Years Old

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Beautiful liquid that shows great age and balance.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Glenmorangie  Glenmorangie 

Allta Private Edition No.10

ABV 51.2%

Comments: Great interplay between the spices and that yeasty note. Moreish too.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Berry Bros & Rudd (exclusively for Abbey Whisky)  Berry Bros & Rudd (exclusively for Abbey Whisky) 

Glen Garioch 

1993, 25 Year Old, Cask 797

ABV 54.9%

Comments: A real Jekyll and Hyde. Shows the power of great balance and ABV.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Gordon & MacPhail Discovery  Gordon & MacPhail Discovery 

Bunnahabhain 

Aged 11 Years

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Nicely knitted together and the perfect Autumn friend.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 The BenRiach  The BenRiach 

Four Cask Matured, Aged 21 Years

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Serious. Separates then knits back together. Sherbet dips in the Cairngorms.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Lady of the Glen  Lady of the Glen 

Secret Islay Distillery, 8 Years Old

ABV 57.8%

Comments: Like doing first aid in a damp forest – a stunning, lovely whisky.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 The Glendronach  The Glendronach 

Single Cask Batch 14, Aged 26 Years

ABV 50.8%

Comments: I’m presuming this is European oak. Stands out in the sea of American oak in this issue, but also brilliant in its own right.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Tamdhu  Tamdhu 

Batch Strength 002

ABV 58.5%

Comments: For the fireside – bonfires or indoors. Should be enjoyed year-round.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Grindlay’s Selection  Grindlay’s Selection 

Glentauchers 

1996

ABV 54.5%

Comments: A very well-made Speyside single malt which anyone should be happy with.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 That Boutique-y Whisky Company  That Boutique-y Whisky Company 

Highland Park 

Batch 1

ABV 44.7%

Comments: A fruity little number, which is well balanced with enough earthy tones to play well with the flighty fruits. Yum!

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 anCnoc  anCnoc 

35 years old

ABV 44.3%

Comments: A real beauty!

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Glenmorangie  Glenmorangie 

Artein

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Has raised the benchmark in how to finish a whisky in wine casks.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Bowmore  Bowmore 

40 Years Old, 1969

ABV 44.8%

Comments: A superb dram but given the price...

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 The Octave  The Octave 

The Glenrothes 

1969, 40 Years Old

ABV 45.8%

Comments: A stylish combination of two distinctive Glenrothes styles: red berries and zesty grapefruit.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 The Glenrothes  The Glenrothes 

25 Years Old

ABV 43.0%

Comments: A rich,rewarding wintery dram. Amazing balance.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Rare Malts Selection  Rare Malts Selection 

Port Ellen 

1978, Aged 22 Years

ABV 60.5%

Comments: Pungent, powerful and appetising. A dram for the Islay-lover and connoisseur. This distillery should be revived.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Talisker  Talisker 

1986, The Distiller's Edition, Amoroso Sherry

ABV 0.0%

Comments: Sensational (both literally and figuratively).

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 The Balvenie  The Balvenie 

21 Years Old, PortWood

ABV 47.6%

Comments: An extremely graceful and charmingly feminine dram.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Talisker  Talisker 

25 Years Old

ABV 45.8%

Comments: Stunning, complex and loaded with layers of flavour and aroma. Would be fun to pair with some sushi.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 The BenRiach  The BenRiach 

30 Years Old

ABV 50.0%

Comments: Soft, subtle and not overwooded. Just shades it over the 25yo this time.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Balblair  Balblair 

Aged 38 Years, Limited Edition

ABV 44.0%

Comments: An enticing expression of old age. Forever young! With elegance and style.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Springbank  Springbank 

1989, Limited Edition Limburg Festival Bottling

ABV 55.8%

Comments: Springbank in pyrotechnic form. The sherry doubles the flavours, but arguably also softens the Campbeltown character.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 The Glenlivet  The Glenlivet 

1967 Cellar Collection

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Jim Cryle has done a wonderful job picking these casks.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 The Balvenie  The Balvenie 

Vintage Cask 1967

ABV 40.0%

Comments: A beautifully balanced classic Speyside whisky.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

  Talisker 

1975, 25 Years Old, Cask Strength

ABV 59.9%

Comments: Less instantly explosive than the regular 10. The flavours in the 25 are more tightly combined and take longer to unfold. You pays your money...

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

  Rare Malts Selection 

Port Ellen 

20 Years Old

ABV 60.9%

Comments: Bring on the caeser salad.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Bowmore  Bowmore 

Claret

ABV 56.0%

Comments: An elaborate malt which enhances Bowmore's association with perfume. Good enough to wear!

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Highland Park  Highland Park 

25 Years Old

ABV 48.1%

Comments: Have this one with dessert.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Glengoyne  Glengoyne 

2000 AD

ABV 51.3%

Comments: Delicious example of maltiness in a whisky. I always enjoy Glengoynes very much, but they invariably leave me wanting a little more.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Glenmorangie  Glenmorangie 

Fino Sherry Wood Finish

ABV 43.0%

Comments: A marriage made in heaven.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Redbreast  Redbreast 

Aged 12 Years

ABV 40.0%

Comments: This is what real pure pot still whiskey is all about, a glorious contradiction of soft fruit and firm grain, oily seeds and sweet wood. World beating stuff.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Virginia Distillery Co.  Virginia Distillery Co. 

Port Cask Finished, Virginia-Highland Whisky

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Well done Virginia, this really is a stunning piece of distilling from the brand.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Tomatin  Tomatin 

Warehouse 6 Collection, The 1977 Edition

ABV 49.0%

Comments: Some great elements roll in here from the nose right through to the palate. A wonderful balance.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Port Ellen  Port Ellen 

11th Release, 1979, 32 Years Old

ABV 52.5%

Comments: Almost perfection, should be tasted outdoors.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Sullivans Cove  Sullivans Cove 

Double Cask Single Malt

ABV 45.0%

Comments: Like eating popping candy and Liquorice shoelaces.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 The GlenDronach  The GlenDronach 

Master Vintage 1993

ABV 48.2%

Comments: A serious bit of a sherry bomb.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Tomatin  Tomatin 

30 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A serious whisky that has a great depth of flavour and aroma. One to take your time over.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Mortlach  Mortlach 

20 Years Old

ABV 43.4%

Comments: Wow, sherry meets fruit. A near perfect marriage.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Langatun  Langatun 

Old Bear

ABV 40.0%

Comments: Just lovely, different and quite breathtaking.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Bowmore  Bowmore 

No.1

ABV 40.0%

Comments: Delightful, an easy going Islay dram, a very gentle character and layered.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 The BenRiach  The BenRiach 

30 Years Old, Authenticus Peated

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Just the foil for a good Cuban cigar. A perfect level of peat too.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 The GlenDronach  The GlenDronach 

14 Years Old Single Cask Batch 14

ABV 55.0%

Comments: A top-drawer dram. Body, power, complexity and interesting development.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Lady of the Glen  Lady of the Glen 

Aultmore 

1992, Aged 23 Years

ABV 51.1%

Comments: Fabulously fresh yet pleasingly complex. Wears its high ABV relatively lightly.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 The GlenDronach  The GlenDronach 

Single Cask Batch 14, Aged 20 Years

ABV 54.6%

Comments: I’m totally nuts about you.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Berrys' Own Selection  Berrys' Own Selection 

Glen Garioch 

1989, 26 Years Old, Cask #7856

ABV 54.6%

Comments: If the palate was as exuberant as the nose then this would have been exceptional.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Smögen  Smögen 

Wee Swede

ABV 62.5%

Comments: Intense and primal. Those Swedes have come up with a cracker again!

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Bruichladdich  Bruichladdich 

The Laddie Eight

ABV 50.0%

Comments: Lemon sherbet and cigar smoke combine to make this a really great example of smoky Scotch whisky.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Berrys' Own Selection  Berrys' Own Selection 

Auchroisk 

1990, 23 Years Old, Cask #21752

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Light and easy drinking, this is a summery dram which would be perfect over ice.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Octomore  Octomore 

07.4 Virgin Oak

ABV 61.2%

Comments: An unmistakable Islay whisky, probably not too old, but worth a look at.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Glen Moray  Glen Moray 

25 Years Old Port Cask Finish, Batch 3

ABV 43.0%

Comments: This could be the most perfect dessert whisky; pour in place of a sweet wine.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Douglas Laing's XOP  Douglas Laing's XOP 

Bowmore 

25 Years Old

ABV 55.1%

Comments: I really like this. Right up my street for a good, solid, peaty whisky.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Ben Nevis  Ben Nevis 

The President’s Cask 23 Years Old

ABV 56.4%

Comments: A fine example of a well matured, high strength, oily and rich Scotch whisky. A very solid performance indeed.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Smögen Svensk  Smögen Svensk 

Sherry Project 1:2, Single Malt

ABV 55.7%

Comments: This is a nicely composed whisky, a hunter’s dram.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Berrys' Own Selection  Berrys' Own Selection 

The Glenlivet 

1973, 38 Years Old, Cask #10658

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Full of Speyside charm and swagger, balance and poise.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Master of Malt  Master of Malt 

Secret Bottlings Series 

30 Years Old

ABV 40.0%

Comments: The liquid equivalent of hiding in the wardrobe, no lion or witch mind you.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Tomatin  Tomatin 

25 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A lovely dram. The perfect summer uplifting drink to share with friends.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 Glenmorangie  Glenmorangie 

Astar

ABV 57.1%

Comments: A gorgeous,luscious dram. 'Morangie to the max.

OVERALL SCORE

9.0

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

15 Years Old Double Cask

ABV 43.0%

Comments: A lovely number with some sweet notes going on in the middle. Honey-laden like a good soul singer.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Aberfeldy  Aberfeldy 

40 Years Old

ABV 50.1%

Comments: Clearly something special going on here. Lovely interplay between the wood and spirit, underpinned with great sweetness.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Mackmyra  Mackmyra 

Vintersol Swedish Single Malt Whisky

ABV 46.1%

Comments: Delightful and gentle on the nose, all the punch is in the taste and finish. Balanced near perfectly.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

  Glenmorangie 

Côte de Nuits

ABV 43.0%

Comments: This one scores highly for delicacy, balance and, especially, complexity.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

10 Years Old

ABV 40.0%

Comments: A king-pin malt which never disappoints.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

  Glenmorangie 

Original

ABV 40.0%

Comments: For my money the best Glenmorangie. I have yet come across: complexity beyond belief. Truly outstanding.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Cragganmore  Cragganmore 

12 Years Old

ABV 40.0%

Comments: It's worth taking the trouble.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

  Redbreast 

Aged 12 Years

ABV 40.0%

Comments: Remains an all-Ireland great and one of the few true pure pot still whiskies around. A treat for even the most experienced connoisseur.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Brora  Brora 

30 Years Old

ABV 52.4%

Comments: Complex. A remarkable malt that thrills but saddens. Here's another light that's gone out.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Talisker  Talisker 

25 Years Old

ABV 56.9%

Comments: Bold, subtle, sweet yet smoky. Class.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Glenmorangie  Glenmorangie 

Single Cask 1784

ABV 55.0%

Comments: Perfect for this time of year, and for me, a dessert whisky.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Tomatin  Tomatin 

50 Years Old

ABV 45.3%

Comments: A seriously lush whisky, shows some age, but those fruits balance it out.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Svensk Rök/Amerikanska Ek  Svensk Rök/Amerikanska Ek 

Swedish Single Malt Whisky

ABV 46.1%

Comments: Lovely stuff. The layers of smoke and sulphur are well integrated into the sweetness of the whole thing. A delight.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Littlemill  Littlemill 

40 Years Old

ABV 46.8%

Comments: Very punchy – think Lowlanders are light and gentle? Think again.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Kyrö  Kyrö 

Single Malt Rye Whiskey No. 1

ABV 47.8%

Comments: Completely off the radar. Massively brave character. Love it.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Teeling  Teeling 

Revival Volume II

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Wonderfully vibrant and inviting, just like an Irish girl I once knew!

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 That Boutique-y Whisky Company  That Boutique-y Whisky Company 

Tormore 

Batch 2

ABV 51.4%

Comments: Caught at just the right time. Any more age on this and it would simply be too dry.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Lady of the Glen  Lady of the Glen 

Tobermory 

1995, 20 Years Old

ABV 56.6%

Comments: A lovely, well balanced dram; sets a benchmark for ‘good, ordinary well-made whisky’.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 The GlenDronach  The GlenDronach 

Peated

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A whisky that has taken on a fair amount of oak influence but a robust spirit has fought back to give a fairly well rounded end product.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Glen Moray  Glen Moray 

Elgin Classic Port Cask Finish

ABV 40.0%

Comments: As comforting as a country kitchen.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 The English Whisky Company  The English Whisky Company 

Chapter 13

ABV 45.0%

Comments: A really, really drinkable whisky. No idea of the price point, but if this is anywhere near 'reasonable' then clear a space for it in your cabinet.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 The Balvenie  The Balvenie 

Madeira Cask 17 Years Old

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Rich and complex. Superbly balanced and elegant. To enjoy with Beethoven's 7th Symphony.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Glenmorangie  Glenmorangie 

The Nectar D'Or

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Long and sweet. Try with soft goat's cheese.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

1940, 35 Years Old

ABV 0.0%

Comments: Not quite the complexity of the 1946 and 1948. Oaky woodiness begins to intrude.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

  Old Malt Cask 

Ardbeg 

Aged 24 Years

ABV 50.0%

Comments: Slightly sweeter than the 1977 but equally good. The sulphury note lets it down.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 The Glenlivet  The Glenlivet 

1969 Cellar Collection

ABV 50.8%

Comments: A very satisfying afterdinner dram.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 

 

aphroaig 

Vintage, Aged 17 Years

ABV 50.3%

Comments: A perfect example of the 'tough guy with a tender heart'

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 The BenRiach  The BenRiach 

Authenticus Peated Malt, Aged 21 Years

ABV 56.7%

Comments: Reveals a rich profile by a succession of aromatic layers. Alcohol is perfectly tamed.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 The Glenturret  The Glenturret 

29 Years Old

ABV 55.6%

Comments: A classic all-round drinking malt in the Highland style. Good to see another bottling from this distillery.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Port Ellen  Port Ellen 

Aged 25 Years, Special Release 2005

ABV 57.4%

Comments: Old, intense and busting for an olifactory fight. Complex and grizzly, like Clint Eastwood in The Unforgiven.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Laphroaig  Laphroaig 

17 Years Old, Feis Ile 2004, Cask Strength

ABV 55.2%

Comments: A touch sophisticated for the likes of me. Where are those stinging iodine notes? They are in there somewhere, but beautifully balanced and rounded.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Glenfiddich  Glenfiddich 

40 Years Old, Rare Collection

ABV 44.0%

Comments: Extraordinary flavour development. An astonishingly complex whisky.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Brora  Brora 

Aged 30 Years, Limited Edition

ABV 55.7%

Comments: Exuberant interplay of sweet and dry flavours, pivoted on a firm malt background.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

  Ardbeg 

Uigeadail

ABV 54.2%

Comments: Some dram!

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

  The Macallan 

Exceptional Cask IV

ABV 57.4%

Comments: A great example of European oak and Macallan in harmony. Exceptional indeed.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

  The Macallan 

1951 Vintage

ABV 49.6%

Comments: A bit scary. A 50 Years Old malt with stunning balance and vivaciousness...but I can't afford it on my wages.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

Forties

ABV 40.0%

Comments: A similar style to 30s but less delicate and more robust.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

Fifties

ABV 40.0%

Comments: Closest to The Macallan of today, appropriately enough.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Yoichi  Yoichi 

15 Years Old

ABV 45.0%

Comments: Creamier than the 10 Years Old, but that softens the peatiness. Between these two, I preferred the peatier ten.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Glenmorangie  Glenmorangie 

The Accord, 12 Years Old

ABV 43.0%

Comments: It’s pretty much the version of a trifle where your aunt is heavy handed with the sherry. Darn yummy to be honest.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Old Pulteney  Old Pulteney 

18 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Great stuff, well balanced and has a lovely subtle maritime quality to it. Definitely one for savouring by the beach bonfire.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Signatory Vintage  Signatory Vintage 

The Glenlivet 

2007, 12 Years Old

ABV 64.1%

Comments: It takes Speyside and turns the perceived style on its head. Dark and mysterious stuff, watch out for the ginger too.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Cù Bòcan  Cù Bòcan 

1988 Vintage Edition

ABV 51.5%

Comments: A well aged whisky which deserves to have some attention and time dedicated to it.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

  Highland Park 

1973

ABV 50.6%

Comments: A warming dram. Well balanced and harmonious.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 The BenRiach  The BenRiach 

15 Years Old Finished in French Red Wine Casks

ABV 57.2%

Comments: Summer is here again, something wonderfully rum-esque. Try it over ice cream with chocolate sauce.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Paul John  Paul John 

Pedro Ximenez, Single Malt Whisky

ABV 48.0%

Comments: I would have this when tending to the barbecue, even chuck some over the meat as it cooks. Awesome stuff.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Tomatin  Tomatin 

Decades II, Limited Edition

ABV 46.0%

Comments: One for the sweet-toothed initially, but judicious water brings out a layer of spice too.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 The GlenAllachie  The GlenAllachie 

15 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A well-defined drop with signs of well-nurtured ageing.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

  Berrys' Own Selection 

Macduff 

1984

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A rich and complex Speysider, having made the best of a well mastered maturation in refill sherry casks.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Lombard Jewels of Scotland  Lombard Jewels of Scotland 

1969

ABV 41.1%

Comments: I’m lost for words!

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Lombard Jewels of Scotland  Lombard Jewels of Scotland 

Springbank 

1969

ABV 41.1%

Comments: Enjoyable, from the first whiff to the last sip. One I could sip endlessly by a fire.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Highland Park  Highland Park 

Twisted Tattoo 16 Years Old

ABV 46.7%

Comments: A great starting dram for an early 80s dinner party.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Tamdhu  Tamdhu 

Gran Reserva

ABV 46.0%

Comments: I cannot advocate a breakfast dram, but if you fancy something on your porridge at night.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 House Tyrell  House Tyrell 

Clynelish Reserve

ABV 51.2%

Comments: Like passing an overly perfumed person on the beach, floral and saline meet.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Mortlach  Mortlach 

16 Years Old

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Oh yes, just as the weather got colder this hit the spot. Warming and balanced.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Jura  Jura 

One and All, 20 Years Old

ABV 51.0%

Comments: Insane fun! Full of attitude. I’m exhausted just drinking it.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Box  Box 

Quercus I, Robur

ABV 50.8%

Comments: Chock-full of flavour from active maturation. More superbly made Swedish whisky.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Lady of the Glen  Lady of the Glen 

Aged 19 Years

ABV 54.6%

Comments: An odd number but once opened up it's good fun, layers of interest wash in.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Glenmorangie  Glenmorangie 

Astar

ABV 52.5%

Comments: Really good whisky, with complexity from a number of angles. Delightful.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Lagavulin  Lagavulin 

8 Years Old 200 Years 1816 - 2016

ABV 48.0%

Comments: Yes, this is fine whisky making, with a liquid designed to be drunk.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Berrys' Own Selection  Berrys' Own Selection 

Glenlossie 

1992, 21 Years Old, Cask #3472

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Another well made, easy to drink, light, malty whisky

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Millstone  Millstone 

Special #7 Heavy Peated

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Lovely. Unmistakably ‘new world’ with big flavour, but it competes shoulder-to-shoulder with Scotch.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Darkness!  Darkness! 

Ben Nevis 

17 Years Old

ABV 49.0%

Comments: A well rounded and sweet whisky with some great flavours, which sings on the palate.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Berrys' Own Selection  Berrys' Own Selection 

Clynelish 

1996, 18 Years Old, #6424

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Like a butterfly in your hand – delicate and beautiful but fleeting and flighty.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Signatory  Signatory 

Clynelish 

1995, Aged 17 Years (hand picked by The Whisky Exchange)

ABV 56.2%

Comments: Lovely and mature, beyond its age statement.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 The Glendronach  The Glendronach 

Parliament 1990 21 Years Old

ABV 48.0%

Comments: A well balanced sherried whisky. Rich, complex with a beautiful finish.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 The Arran Malt  The Arran Malt 

4 Years Old, 1997 Single Cask Sherry Butt

ABV 56.3%

Comments: Keep this for Christmas and drink it with the pudding.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Balcones  Balcones 

Texas Single Malt Whisky

ABV 53.0%

Comments: Butter in a glass. Moreish, with sweet stone fruits and lashings of honey. This is stunning.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Berry Bros & Rudd  Berry Bros & Rudd 

16 Years Old, Orkney Islands

ABV 53.6%

Comments: Oh yes… this is fine stuff indeed. Well balanced with a gorgeous smoke profile.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

  Frisky Whisky 

Caol Ila 

25 Years Old

ABV 54.0%

Comments: Balanced, complex. Highest recommendation.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

Quest Collection Terra

ABV 41.3%

Comments: Big and robust-rather like an alcoholic fruit salad.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 The GlenDronach  The GlenDronach 

Grandeaur Batch 10

ABV 50.1%

Comments: At first a big bruiser, but as you get to know it, it has a sweeter side.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Mortlach  Mortlach 

12 Years Old

ABV 43.4%

Comments: Perfect balance and weight.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Nikka  Nikka 

Coffey Malt

ABV 45.0%

Comments: So pleasing to smell that one could wear the stuff on a date.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 The BenRiach  The BenRiach 

Tawny Port Wood Finish 21 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A really sweet and delicious little number. Right strength, right balance. Good job!

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Highland Park  Highland Park 

Thorfinn

ABV 45.1%

Comments: A lovely old Highland Park, but a bit hard on the wallet.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Mackmyra  Mackmyra 

Moment Vintage

ABV 48.6%

Comments: A cracking whisky from Sweden. Praise for the Swedes coming from a man who holds a Norwegian passport – it must be good!

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Talisker  Talisker 

Skye

ABV 45.8%

Comments: Some people say that Scotch has lost its edge, especially compared to bigger, more bombastic world whiskies. They need to try this.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Benromach  Benromach 

1976

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A serious multilayered and intriguing dram, that just keeps revealing more and more over time.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Wemyss Malts  Wemyss Malts 

Teaninich 

1982, Winter Spice

ABV 44.4%

Comments: A lovely dram. Sensuous and complex.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Auchentoshan  Auchentoshan 

36 Years Old, 1975

ABV 46.9%

Comments: A well matured, balanced and complex. Water fades its colourful character though.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Scott's Selection  Scott's Selection 

Highland Park 

1981, 20 Years Old

ABV 48.5%

Comments: Well aged and looked after, a lovely dram indeed.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection  Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection 

Glen Mhor 

1966, 44 Years Old

ABV 45.0%

Comments: The unpleasant note at first nose goes away. A rich and deep matured whisky which brings out memories of invigorating walks in the woods on a cold frosty morning.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Ardbeg  Ardbeg 

Rennaissance

ABV 55.9%

Comments: A big lad. I was right. Ardbeg Renaissance.Unmistakable, uncompromising. Excellent.

OVERALL SCORE

8.9

 Highfern  Highfern 

Angels' Nectar 

Islay Edition, Single Malt

ABV 47.0%

Comments: A great balance of what smoky whisky can offer, that mix of citrus and wood smoke. Refreshing.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Denis Charpentier Group  Denis Charpentier Group 

Eternity 

Emerald Reserve, 12 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A solid and well made whisky, nicely put together with some great flavours.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Highland Park  Highland Park 

Triskelion

ABV 43.2%

Comments: Perfect pre-dinner dram to ease and soothe the day’s problems. Very lovely.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

  Aberfeldy 

14 Years Old Single Cask

ABV 58.1%

Comments: Aberfeldy on steroids.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

  Connemara 

Peated Single Malt

ABV 40.0%

Comments: Lots happening. Chimney pots of smoke. I love this whiskey.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Dekanta  Dekanta 

Kigai from the Ki Series

ABV 60.0%

Comments: Packed with flavour that hits you bit by bit. Glorious stuff.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 The BenRiach  The BenRiach 

Batch 16 Cask 3791 Port

ABV 55.3%

Comments: A stonking whisky with some lovely red fruit elements.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Glengoyne  Glengoyne 

Legacy Series: Chapter One

ABV 48.0%

Comments: Very hot for its ABV, but very entertaining for sure.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 The Dalmore  The Dalmore 

1996, Vintage Port Collection, Aged 20 Years

ABV 45.0%

Comments: Not fully rounded but, by thunder, this is tasty. You’ll need a sweet tooth…

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 The GlenDronach  The GlenDronach 

Peated Port Wood

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Just a lovely everyday dram – essential for the cabinet.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Abbey Whisky  Abbey Whisky 

Anon 

Batch 2, Aged 17 Years, AW 10th Anniversary

ABV 53.8%

Comments: Hipflask, spade, onion sets, biltong and burning off-cuts in the evening light. Blissful.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Nikka  Nikka 

From the Barrel

ABV 51.0%

Comments: A delight of a dram – characterful, yet accessible to all too.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

  John Dewar & Sons 

Aberfeldy 

14 Years Old

ABV 58.1%

Comments: Aberfeldy on steroids.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Lagavulin  Lagavulin 

25 Years Old

ABV 57.0%

Comments: A glorious dram let down by a slight hint of bitterness on the back. Still a high scorer though.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Royal Brackla  Royal Brackla 

16 Years Old

ABV 40.0%

Comments: Really very nice indeed. Maybe could have done with being at 42 or 43% ABV.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Isle of Arran Distillery  Isle of Arran Distillery 

Smugglers' Series Vol.1 'The Illicit Stills'

ABV 56.4%

Comments: A wonderful whisky with the right balance of age, smoke, spices and fruits.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Spirit of Hven  Spirit of Hven 

Tycho's Star

ABV 41.8%

Comments: Very well engineered, as you would expect from a country which holds function and form so highly.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Glen Moray  Glen Moray 

Elgin Classic Peated

ABV 40.0%

Comments: A delicate but complex whisky that I’d happily drink both during hot summer days and cold winter nights. Versatile.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Glengoyne  Glengoyne 

25 Years Old Highland Single Malt

ABV 48.0%

Comments: It feels old but not fragile.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Speciality Drinks  Speciality Drinks 

Port Askaig 

Cask Strength, 12 Years Old

ABV 45.8%

Comments: A beautifully balanced islander. The marine aromatic display is just enticing, constantly teasing the malty sweet heart.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Glenfarclas The Family Casks  Glenfarclas The Family Casks 

Release X, 1985

ABV 44.9%

Comments: Summer is here, a gorgeous dram.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Gordon & MacPhail  Gordon & MacPhail 

Mortlach 

1971

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Shows its age well and with balance.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Glenfarclas  Glenfarclas 

1970 Sherry Hogshead

ABV 51.7%

Comments: That old timer has surprisingly kept a high strength and a vibrant character. Oak is overwhelming but in an elegant way. That could be an old cognac.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Tomatin  Tomatin 

1976, 30 Years Old

ABV 49.3%

Comments: Rich and complex old fellow. Has kept all his buoyancy and liveliness. So different from the previous one (Tomatin 1967).

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Springbank  Springbank 

1997, 11 Years Old, Madeira Wood

ABV 55.1%

Comments: A rich character,slowly displaying a beautiful array of spices.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Tomatin  Tomatin 

30 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Excellent stuff and not to be overlooked at all.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Glenmorangie  Glenmorangie 

Signet

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A bold and some would say a-typical. It works is a valid and successful improvisation on the theme.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Douglas Laing  Douglas Laing 

Laphroaig 

1987, 15 Years Old

ABV 50.0%

Comments: A lean and lively Laphroaig, more smoky than seaweedy. The flavours are long and persistent. Enjoyable, more-ish and appetising.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Balblair  Balblair 

1979 Vintage

ABV 43.0%

Comments: A vibrant and enticing nose. Really good stuff though.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Glenmorangie  Glenmorangie 

'Truffle' Oak Reserve

ABV 60.5%

Comments: A superb fruity expression, with a summery aromatic profile. Water makes it even more sensuous. Definitely morish.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

15 Years Old, Fine Oak

ABV 0.0%

Comments: Takes time to open but worth the wait. The complete package and arguably the best.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Signatory  Signatory 

Laphroaig 

Un-Chillfiltered Collection 1988, Aged 15 Years

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A huge, rich and strangely elegant Laphroaig. Miles better than the official 15 Years Old.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Glenmorangie  Glenmorangie 

Tain L'Hermitage, 1975

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A resounding success. Would make a great, if expensive, Rob Roy.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

  The Scotch Malt Whisky Society 

The Yamazaki 

119.2 – A night at the opera, 1979, 24 Years Old, Japanese Oak Cask

ABV 57.4%

Comments: A breakfast malt? Splendidly complex, with Japanese oak adding that extra touch of distinctiveness.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

Twenties

ABV 40.0%

Comments: Despite a relatively full colour, suggesting plenty of sherry, the Macallan flavours shine through. The driest of these bottlings.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 The Balvenie  The Balvenie 

Aged 21 Years, PortWood

ABV 40.0%

Comments: Finishing is all about striking a balance. Here, the port just nudges the spirit into a new space but never dominates. Classy.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

  Gordon & MacPhail 

Mortlach 

1938, 60 Years Old

ABV 40.0%

Comments: A great age, but it has matured beautifully.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Auchentoshan  Auchentoshan 

1978, 18 Years Old

ABV 58.8%

Comments: A must for those in search of the best a distillery can offer. Distilled when the stills performed in perfect harmony.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 

 

Cragganmore 

12 Years Old

ABV 40.0%

Comments: Balances richness and fragrance superbly.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Glengoyne  Glengoyne 

30 Years Old

ABV 46.8%

Comments: A truly stonking whisky.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Glen Moray  Glen Moray 

21 Years Old Portwood Finish

ABV 46.3%

Comments: The liquid equivalent of a weighted blanket, so comforting.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Lark  Lark 

Classic Lark

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Really interesting stuff, does make you want more once the finish dies away though.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 The Lakes  The Lakes 

The Whiskymaker’s Reserve, No.2

ABV 60.9%

Comments: A lovely drop that takes water well if needed. Rammed full of sunshine-laden fruits. Time for a picnic.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Tomatin  Tomatin 

Legacy

ABV 43.0%

Comments: A lovely ball of spices and fruit, with layered sweetness. One to take a little time over.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 The GlenAllachie  The GlenAllachie 

18 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Like working in the garden in late summer, stopping for a cold beer with the sun warming the soil. Restful and soulful.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

Edition No. 5

ABV 48.5%

Comments: Rich and caramelly. Gorgeous.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Highland Park  Highland Park 

Thorfinn

ABV 45.1%

Comments: A very well made and well aged dram. Double thumbs-up!

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Ardbeg  Ardbeg 

10 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A punch in the chops from a stroppy Islay middleweight. Flavour-packed yet delicate.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Glenmorangie  Glenmorangie 

Fino Sherry Wood Finish

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Outstanding stuff from Glenmorangie, and for my money their most delicate expression yet.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

  Bowmore 

Darkest

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Not that dark - just tawny. Whisky in its mid teens, I would say, but from superb sherry casks.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

  Laphroaig 

10 Years Old

ABV 40.0%

Comments: A gentle giant.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Tamnavulin  Tamnavulin 

Sherry Cask Edition

ABV 40.0%

Comments: A great dram, that long lovely finish is intense, tannin laden and just wonderful really.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 The BenRiach  The BenRiach 

Sherry Wood

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Great stuff, very autumnal on the nose, but the building spices are quite something indeed.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Bramble Whisky  Bramble Whisky 

Glenglassaugh 

Highland Single Malt

ABV 53.5%

Comments: A great winter warmer, so rich and the smoke doesn’t dominate. Balance is wonderful.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Glenfiddich Experimental Series  Glenfiddich Experimental Series 

Fire & Cane

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Really intresting floral lead dram. I love the way the smoke seems to lurk, and that spice hit is great. Lovely stuff.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Port Ellen  Port Ellen 

37 Years Old, Special Release (17th Release)

ABV 51.0%

Comments: A ton of character, charm and individuality - which is rare these days.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Ardbeg  Ardbeg 

Twenty Something, Guaranteed 23 Years Old

ABV 46.3%

Comments: A classic example of this sort.The kind of approachable Islay that will end up charming most.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Gordon & MacPhail Discovery  Gordon & MacPhail Discovery 

Caol Ila 

13 Years Old

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Wonderful smoke and sweetness.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Lady of the Glen  Lady of the Glen 

1991, Aged 27 Years

ABV 43.2%

Comments: A perfect balance between spicy and refreshing.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 The GlenDronach  The GlenDronach 

24 Years Old Single Cask Batch 14

ABV 58.4%

Comments: Really intriguing. Layers of complexity scream ‘winter dram’. For when the nights draw in…

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Lombard  Lombard 

Springbank 1991

ABV 50.0%

Comments: Not your average Campbeltown malt. It bears more than a passing resemblance to Arran!

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Tomatin  Tomatin 

1971, Warehouse 6 Collection

ABV 45.8%

Comments: The oak influence here has masked a little of the spirit nature and I’d say needed less time in oak.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Laphroaig  Laphroaig 

Lore

ABV 48.0%

Comments: Really soft, delicate and warming. Brown sugar in hot coffee.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Lombard Jewels of Scotland  Lombard Jewels of Scotland 

Glen Keith 

1985

ABV 41.9%

Comments: I’m sure Whinnie the Pooh would love this, all runny honey sweetness.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Paul John  Paul John 

Single Cask Peated #777, Indian Single Malt

ABV 59.2%

Comments: The posh bacon sandwich of the whisky world. If supermarkets served this, they would add on a few quid, that’s for sure.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 The Single Malts of Scotland  The Single Malts of Scotland 

Longmorn 

1992, 21 Years Old

ABV 49.7%

Comments: Often sherry casks can overpower. Here everything works in partnership. An example of togetherness being better.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 The Glendronach  The Glendronach 

Special Cask,1993

ABV 59.1%

Comments: Sherry shines through all the way with great elegance and complexity.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Benromach  Benromach 

30 Years Old

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Balanced and poised.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Wemyss Vintage Malts  Wemyss Vintage Malts 

Caol Ila 

1984, 24 Years Old, Sea Smoke

ABV 55.0%

Comments: This independent bottler is starting to grab the attention. Again, a stunning Islay malt. Where are they finding the casks?

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Yoichi  Yoichi 

1988, 20 Years Old

ABV 55.0%

Comments: Another welcome addition to the wonderful world of whisky.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

  Rare Malts Selection 

Port Ellen 

1978, 20 Years Old

ABV 60.9%

Comments: An expressive, arousing, version of this fine malt.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 The Balvenie  The Balvenie 

15 Years Old, Single Barrel

ABV 50.4%

Comments: Arguably the ultimate Speyside dram, though the Glenfiddich Solera gives it a close run. A kaleidoscope of flavours.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

  The Macallan 

Replica, 1861

ABV 42.7%

Comments: Like the touch of peat-when's that batch getting bottled?

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Cragganmore  Cragganmore 

17 Years Old

ABV 55.5%

Comments: Elegant, complex and still forceful. It took water and developed well, holding its structure and continuing to interest.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Balblair  Balblair 

1997 Vintage

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Again, pleasant very pretty. A really good example of American oak maturation.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Chieftain's  Chieftain's 

Port Ellen 

Aged 24 Years

ABV 59.4%

Comments: Complex stuff going on here. A really rewarding Port Ellen.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Glengoyne  Glengoyne 

Aged 32 Years, Single Cask

ABV 48.7%

Comments: Complex, old, not perfect, but good darned fun!

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Signatory Straight from the Cask  Signatory Straight from the Cask 

Port Ellen 

Aged 24 Years, Burgundy finish

ABV 58.8%

Comments: Lots happening here. A complex and highly unusual expression of Port Ellen.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

  Duncan Taylor 

Bruichladdich 

1969, 33 Years Old

ABV 48.7%

Comments: Good balance - has stood up to its cask well, retaining a zest not overwhelmed by age.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Connoisseur's Choice  Connoisseur's Choice 

Ardbeg 

1974

ABV 43.0%

Comments: A classic Ardbeg.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

1989, Exceptional Cask V

ABV 59.2%

Comments: A big boy, but has sufficient sweetness to balance the oak.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

  Douglas Laing 

Laphroaig 

16 Years Old (Bottled for the Limburg Whisky Fair)

ABV 56.1%

Comments: At first, I did not recognise this as a Laphroaig. Then I thought that age must have muted its attack, but 16 is scarcely venerable. Can a whisky be an old fogey?

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Rare Malts Selection  Rare Malts Selection 

Brora 

1982, Aged 20 Years

ABV 58.1%

Comments: Refreshing start; soothing finish. Quite a trick.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Bruichladdich  Bruichladdich 

Vintage 1973

ABV 40.2%

Comments: Superb balance and complexity. A belter.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Kingsbury  Kingsbury 

Islay 1973, 27 Years Old

ABV 47.4%

Comments: Every connoisseur should get his hands on this at any cost. A classic among classics.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Cadenhead's  Cadenhead's 

Rosebank 

1989, 9 Years Old

ABV 43.0%

Comments: All of the characteristic floweriness of Rosebank, but with some roundness.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

  The Macallan 

1970, 32 Years Old, Vintage

ABV 54.9%

Comments: A classic, classy Macallan with added richness. A splendid autumnal dram. Perfect match for dark chocolate cake.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

  The Macallan 

1937, 37 Years Old, Vintage

ABV 43.0%

Comments: A rich, smooth expression of The Macallan. Relatively light in colour. Seems stronger than it really is.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 The Glenlivet  The Glenlivet 

1959 Cellar Collection

ABV 41.7%

Comments: No woodiness at 43 Years Old, instead incredible intensity and freshness. Truly remarkable.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Talisker  Talisker 

28 Years Old

ABV 43.3%

Comments: Amazingly little wood impact for a whisky of this age. Not the most robust Talisker but a cracker nonetheless.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

  Signatory 

Highland Park 

1988

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A Norse nose, concentrated and delicious with more smoke than you normally find, though maybe a little woody.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Rare Malts Selection  Rare Malts Selection 

Brora 

Aged 21 Years

ABV 56.9%

Comments: A good example of Brora as a distinctive maritime malt. Very appetising indeed, but quite different from Talisker, for example.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Bowmore  Bowmore 

Darkest

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Forget expresso and cappuccino, try this for breakfast with a fat Havana. Hedonistic!

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Murray McDavid  Murray McDavid 

Springbank 

1965

ABV 46.0%

Comments: The characteristic salt and coconut characteristics of Springbank are very evident in this bottling, but perhaps overwhelmingly so. I may need more time to understand this one.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Longrow  Longrow 

10 Years Old, Sherrywood

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Many blenders feel that second-fill sherry casks give a more balanced result than first-fill. This whisky is a lesson in that technique.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

  The Glenlivet 

1970 Vintage

ABV 56.6%

Comments: Enjoyable, but I expected a little more.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Aberlour  Aberlour 

30 Years Old

ABV 43.0%

Comments: A really excellent and classy Aberlour showing amazing complexity for its age.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Glenfiddich  Glenfiddich 

15 Years Old, Solera Reserve

ABV 40.0%

Comments: A classic.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

  Ardbeg 

17 Years Old

ABV 40.0%

Comments: I admit to being a little biased here as I did have a hand in putting this whisky together. But I must say I adore it for its wonderful balance.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Bushmills  Bushmills 

Millennium Malt

ABV 40.0%

Comments: This is Bushmills at its peak.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Aberlour  Aberlour 

15 Years Old, Sherry Wood

ABV 40.0%

Comments: A biggish-bodied Aberlour which helps to lengthen the complex effects of the double maturation.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Adelphi  Adelphi 

Linkwood 

17 Years Old

ABV 64.2%

Comments: Linkwood always evokes thoughts of sweetmeats, sometimes delicate, on other occasions more robust. This is in the latter mood: down-to-earth sweetness.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

  Connemara 

Single Malt Irish whiskey

ABV 40.0%

Comments: The revival of rustic peatiness adds a whole new element to today's palette of Irish whiskey flavours.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

  Rare Malts Selection 

Brora 

1977, 21 Years Old

ABV 56.9%

Comments: A lovely coastal malt. It's a shame that its surviving brother Clynelish is more muted.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Oban  Oban 

1980, The Distillers Edition, Montilla

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Demonstrably an evocative whisky. Salty and winey, but neither as overt as in the comparable Glenmorangie Fino.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Highland Park  Highland Park 

12 Years Old

ABV 40.0%

Comments: A beautifully balance classic islander.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 The Balvenie  The Balvenie 

10 Years Old, Founder's Reserve

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Balvenie has long been a favourite, and this expression is sublime. A riposte to any who claim that all Speysiders are much of a muchness.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Auchentoshan  Auchentoshan 

1966, 31 Years Old

ABV 43.5%

Comments: A fine whisky, but does something as fresh and soft benefit from quite so much ageing?

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Aberlour  Aberlour 

a'bunadh

ABV 59.6%

Comments: Darker, drier and more spicily assertive than the earlier version, despite only a slight difference in ages.

OVERALL SCORE

8.8

 Abbey Whisky  Abbey Whisky 

Glenglassaugh 

7 Years Old, 2012, Cask 563, AW Exclusive

ABV 58.7%

Comments: A sherry slap, but tempered with those additional lovely sweet components.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Ardbeg  Ardbeg 

Traigh Bhan, 19 Years Old

ABV 46.2%

Comments: The peaty side of Islay and at its best too. OA log burner full of peat briquettes.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Scapa  Scapa 

Glansa, Batch 5

ABV 40.0%

Comments: A belter despite its ABV. Don’t let the low strength fool you, this is punchy and full of flavour.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 The GlenAllachie  The GlenAllachie 

12 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A whisky for sitting down and throwing the cork away with friends.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Lincolnshire Spirit  Lincolnshire Spirit 

Whisky Spirit

ABV 41.0%

Comments: This has serious promise if nurtured properly. Clean and fruity with a great deal of vigour.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection  Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection 

Longmorn 

1966

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Weaponised sherry in a cigar lounge.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Jura  Jura 

Tide, 21 Years Old

ABV 46.2%

Comments: Taking a hipflask in to an antiquarian bookshop while eating a chocolate orange.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 The Whisky Exchange  The Whisky Exchange 

Lochside 

1981, Oloroso Sherry Reserve

ABV 57.1%

Comments: A belter of a bottling. Recommended.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Glenfiddich  Glenfiddich 

Spirit of a Nation, 29 Years Old, South Pole Challenge 2013

ABV 48.8%

Comments: A heart warming dram and well integrated as well.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Signatory Vintage  Signatory Vintage 

1995, 23 Years Old

ABV 55.4%

Comments: Approaching the sherry bomb territory. This should have a place in your drinking repertoire.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Lagavulin  Lagavulin 

12 Years Old

ABV 56.1%

Comments: A complex yet approachable Islay.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Mackmyra  Mackmyra 

Prestige

ABV 46.1%

Comments: Pretty impressive and layered.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Ben Nevis  Ben Nevis 

Forgotten Bottlings, 32 Years Old

ABV 50.5%

Comments: Shows good, careful ageing, with a lovely balance of fruit and spices.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Ardbeg  Ardbeg 

Drum - Committee Edition

ABV 52.0%

Comments: Has me thinking of a smoky Piña Colada, just for fun.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Gordon & MacPhail  Gordon & MacPhail 

Caol Ila 

1968

ABV 52.5%

Comments: Has a depth of age but still with some of the youthful swagger left.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Talisker  Talisker 

8 Years Old, 2018 Special Releases

ABV 59.4%

Comments: A good mix of old-school TCP notes and sweetness. A lovely whisky.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Tomatin  Tomatin 

15 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Another Autumn tinged stunner.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Highland Park  Highland Park 

50 Years Old

ABV 42.5%

Comments: A very impressive drop. Shows the signs of age, and having aged gracefully.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Whisky Galore  Whisky Galore 

Aultmore 

Aged 8 Years

ABV 46.0%

Comments: This is simply a beautiful, uncomplicated, unfussy companion.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Blair Athol  Blair Athol 

Aged 23 Years, Special Release

ABV 58.4%

Comments: A bracing dram – one’s mouth puckers.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Smögen  Smögen 

7 Years Old

ABV 60.3%

Comments: Raises the bar for Sweden, great stuff indeed.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Gordon & MacPhail  Gordon & MacPhail 

10 Years Old (bottled for The Whisky Shop Dufftown)

ABV 57.9%

Comments: Bold, sweet and smoky. With added rocks.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Douglas Laing Old Particular  Douglas Laing Old Particular 

Laphroaig 

Consortium of Cards, 18 Years Old

ABV 50.0%

Comments: I love my peat, but it dominates to the detriment of others here, else I would have marked it even higher.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Glenmorangie  Glenmorangie 

The Tayne

ABV 43.0%

Comments: A very satisfying dram.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Smögen Svensk  Smögen Svensk 

Sherry Project 1:3

ABV 53.7%

Comments: Ended up tasting like a mouthful of hazelnuts. Cracking…

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 

 

Glenmorangie 

Milsean Private Edition

ABV 46.0%

Comments: This is first class whisky making. Kudos to the team behind this.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Glenmorangie  Glenmorangie 

A Midwinter Night's Dram

ABV 43.0%

Comments: A really fantastic, fruity dram which reminds me of the first time I tried Jolly Rancher sweets. Great balance, great flavours.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Lombard  Lombard 

Teaninich 

1984

ABV 40.0%

Comments: Wonderfully, fantastically, amazingly well made whisky. Well done.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Edinburgh Whisky  Edinburgh Whisky 

Glenlivet

ABV 46.0%

Comments: This needed air and some time in the glass to come to life. Once it did, it revealed a unique flavour profile which was enhanced by a tinge of sulphur, unusual for a single malt.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Westward  Westward 

Single Barrel, Oregon Malt Whiskey

ABV 45.0%

Comments: A surprisingly complex and flavoursome whiskey, with good balance, the nose alone puts a smile on my face. A fun whiskey!

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Berrys' Own Selection  Berrys' Own Selection 

Glengoyne 

2000, 13 Years Old, Cask #1073

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A very well aged whisky indeed. Would work perfectly in an Old Fashioned.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Wemyss Malts  Wemyss Malts 

Bunnahabhain 

1991, Oysters With Lemon Pearls

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Well balanced, with enough going on to make this a very good choice for anyone new to peat smoke.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 The GlenDronach  The GlenDronach 

Tawny Port Finish

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Elegant, feminine and flirtatious. Gives you the wink and easy to drink.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Glen Garioch  Glen Garioch 

Vintage 1998, Wine Cask Matured

ABV 48.0%

Comments: I was impressed by this. No individual star in the tasting notes, but a team effort to create the World Cup winner of whiskies. Is this the start of a new era?

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Wemyss Malts  Wemyss Malts 

Bunnahabhain 

1997, The Bosun's Dram

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Where is the seafood platter? A lovely dram with a perfect balance between the malty flavours and the gentle smoke.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Ardbeg  Ardbeg 

Auriverdes

ABV 49.9%

Comments: A classic Kildalton malt. A classic Ardbeg with a little plus (the toasty note).

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Kilchoman  Kilchoman 

Bourbon Cask 2008

ABV 61.0%

Comments: Young, intense and alcoholic!

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Talisker  Talisker 

Aged 35 Years

ABV 54.6%

Comments: These Talisker releases just keep getting better, and it does well with age.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 The BenRiach  The BenRiach 

Heredotus Famosus Pedro Ximinez Finish

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Fantastic balance and richness of character.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Duncan Taylor  Duncan Taylor 

Cragganmore 

1985, 25 Years Old

ABV 48.3%

Comments: Great stuff, keeps your taste buds working hard.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Tamdhu  Tamdhu 

Batch Strength No. 005

ABV 59.8%

Comments: That ABV is well hidden, but this one leads you straight into the orchard.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Kavalan  Kavalan 

Ex-Bourbon Oak

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Such a delicate drop, this one. It is quite refreshing.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Glengoyne  Glengoyne 

Cuartillo

ABV 40.0%

Comments: A really gentle yet complex whisky that offers much more once it is left for a little.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Seven Seals  Seven Seals 

Peated Double Wood Finish Cask Proof

ABV 58.7%

Comments: Hello Switzerland and welcome to the party…oh you brought a bottle as well!

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 The Dalmore  The Dalmore 

25 Years Old

ABV 42.0%

Comments: It is liquid gold and very seductive!

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Tomatin  Tomatin 

2006 Amontillado Finish

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Wow this is a whopper for the ABV; huge and punchy and punchy and huge.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Springbank  Springbank 

Aged 10 Years

ABV 40.0%

Comments: A worthy replacement for the previous cask vatting, another complex Campbeltown beauty.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Bushmills  Bushmills 

16 Years Old

ABV 40.0%

Comments: Absolutely charming Bushmills. Expertly composed.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

  Longmorn 

15 Years Old

ABV 45.0%

Comments: A cracker. Now Pernod will you please do what Seagram refused to do and start selling it (and Strathisla)?

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

  Ardbeg 

Lord of the Isles, 25 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Lots of flavour development, complexity and refinement. Very elegant, but where is the clamour of battle?

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Caol Ila  Caol Ila 

Cask Strength

ABV 55.0%

Comments: A young cracker. Don't pass this up.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Talisker  Talisker 

25 Years Old

ABV 57.8%

Comments: Rich and luscious. Needs a dash of water to cut spirit harshness. The marine influence is overwhelmed by wood but in a charming way.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Old Pulteney  Old Pulteney 

Aged 17 Years

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A complex, paradoxical individual for complex individuals.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Method and Madness  Method and Madness 

French Limousin

ABV 46.0%

Comments: One for the sweet-toothed, and possible an excellent accompaniment to a pint of stout.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Cù Bòcan  Cù Bòcan 

1990

ABV 52.9%

Comments: Floral and heady, dead-heading roses after the rain.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Elixir Distillers  Elixir Distillers 

Port Askaig 

34 Years Old

ABV 49.7%

Comments: Well cared for and impressively fresh for its years.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Glengoyne  Glengoyne 

Teapot Dram

ABV 59.3%

Comments: Teetering on the sherry bomb territory, very lovely and very moreish.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Tullibardine  Tullibardine 

Custodians 1962

ABV 40.1%

Comments: Like being in a vintage MGB GT. Seriously easy drinking but depth if you look.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Berry Bros. & Rudd  Berry Bros. & Rudd 

The Arran Malt 

1996, 21 Years Old

ABV 46.4%

Comments: Takes its time to balance itself, but it does. A whole sensory and flavour work out.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Wemyss Malts  Wemyss Malts 

Aberfeldy 

1994, Banquet of Fruits

ABV 46.0%

Comments: The apple of my eye. Plenty of vanilla-y American Oak influence in this, but it’s balanced out by all that fruit and funk.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Loch Lomond  Loch Lomond 

Inchmurrin Madeira Wood Finish

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A very solid and dependable whisky.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 The Dalmore  The Dalmore 

Luceo

ABV 40.0%

Comments: A good, middle-of-the road solid whisky.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Ailsa Bay  Ailsa Bay 

Single Malt Scotch Whisky

ABV 48.9%

Comments: A quality spirit balancing smoke, citrus, sweetness. Serve in a hip-flask or a highball

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 The Glenlivet  The Glenlivet 

Guardian's Chapter

ABV 48.7%

Comments: You could argue that it’s a bit simple but when it delivers simple like this, who needs complexity?

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 The Glenlivet  The Glenlivet 

Nàdurra Oloroso

ABV 60.7%

Comments: Belt and braces style of whisky, robust!

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 The GlenDronach  The GlenDronach 

Sauternes Cask Finish 12 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: I was disturbed at first by a kind of cheesy note; but on time, the nose blossomed into a pastry-like aromatic palate. Good spicy kick. An uplifting whisky.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Ardbeg  Ardbeg 

Ardbog

ABV 52.1%

Comments: Like walking into a cottage where a roast is cooking and a peat fire is burning low.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Duncan Taylor Dimensions  Duncan Taylor Dimensions 

Glenburgie 

1985, 26 Years Old

ABV 55.2%

Comments: An enticing nose and lively palate. I prefer it neat than diluted as I think water cuts too many edges... Try it to your taste!

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 The Whisky Exchange Masterpieces  The Whisky Exchange Masterpieces 

Bowmore 18 Years Old 1993

ABV 61.6%

Comments: That whisky needs a dash of water to cut the edges. Clean, big with that wonderful exotic fruit character that some Bowmore proudly display.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Talisker  Talisker 

1981, 30 Years Old

ABV 57.3%

Comments: A well matured whisky. Rich, complex, displaying both outdoor and indoor flavours. Wintery.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Brora  Brora 

1980 30 Years Old

ABV 54.3%

Comments: Well balanced, clean. A pleasant malty core and an appetising freshness.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Old Pulteney  Old Pulteney 

Isabella Fortuna WK499

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Another excellent Pulteney.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Glen Garioch  Glen Garioch 

25 Years Old, 1986

ABV 54.6%

Comments: More well-chosen wood.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Brora  Brora 

25 Years Old

ABV 56.3%

Comments: A big boy. But if you give it time,you'll tame it. The fruity notes display is really scrumptious.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

  Signatory 

Caol Ila 

1984

ABV 40.0%

Comments: An excellent example of Caol Illa, a highly distinctive malt that is gaining in recognition.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 The BenRiach  The BenRiach 

25 Years Old

ABV 50.0%

Comments: Another killer from Mr Walker's warehouse. Distillery of the year for me.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Dewar Rattray Cask Collection  Dewar Rattray Cask Collection 

The Macallan 

17 Years Old

ABV 58.4%

Comments: Plump. A pudding whisky. Excellent.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Dewar Rattray Cask Collection  Dewar Rattray Cask Collection 

Bowmore 

14 Years Old

ABV 57.8%

Comments: A beautiful Islay malt in a sherry refill dressing. Rich aromatic development, great combination of strength and sweetness.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection  Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection 

Balblair 

1973

ABV 45.0%

Comments: A sherry beast with rubbery horns. A drink to be chewed rather than sipped. It caught me in the right mood and I liked it.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Duncan Taylor  Duncan Taylor 

Glen Garioch 

1988, 17 Years Old

ABV 54.6%

Comments: Has the X factor.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Glengoyne  Glengoyne 

Aged 37 Years, Single Cask Sherry Butt

ABV 47.6%

Comments: Luxuriant without decadence. Aristocratic.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Old Pulteney  Old Pulteney 

Aged 17 Years

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Focused and balanced.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

30 Years Old, Fine Oak

ABV 0.0%

Comments: Great nose, firm palate. Wood dominating a little.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

21 Years Old, Fine Oak

ABV 0.0%

Comments: A cracker, typical of old (and older style) Speyside.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

  Douglas Laing Old & Rare Platinum Selection 

Glen Garioch 

1968, Aged 35 Years

ABV 56.0%

Comments: Old brocade, velvet curtains, tweed.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Chivas Brothers  Chivas Brothers 

The Glenlivet 

1987, Aged 16 Years, Cask Strength

ABV 56.6%

Comments: Has the wow factor that separates the very good from the truly great.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Signatory  Signatory 

Mortlach 

Un-Chillfiltered Collection 1989, Aged 13 Years

ABV 46.0%

Comments: The most complex and structured of the Mortlachs in this tasting.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

  Vintage Malt Whisky Co. 

Classic of Islay 

Cask Strength

ABV 60.2%

Comments: A punchy, deep malt. Good balance.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Ardbeg  Ardbeg 

1976, Single Cask Committee bottling

ABV 51.0%

Comments: A 'no bones about it' Islay whisky, and a fine example of Ardbeg.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Cragganmore  Cragganmore 

29 Years Old

ABV 52.5%

Comments: At this age, more complex and elegant than ever. No obvious sherry.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

  The Scotch Malt Whisky Society 

The Yamazaki 

119.3 – Soft fudge and angelica, 1993, Aged 10 Years

ABV 56.2%

Comments: A surprising amount of peat in this usually very delicate malt.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Murray McDavid Mission II  Murray McDavid Mission II 

Linkwood 

1973, Aged 29 Years

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Very sophisticated bittersweet flavours. Adults only.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Murray McDavid Mission  Murray McDavid Mission 

The Glenlivet 

1974

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Softness and subtlety is underrated these days, but can be more complex as any big old bruiser.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

Replica, 1841

ABV 41.7%

Comments: Controlled. A very drinkable young Macallan.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Bruichladdich  Bruichladdich 

20 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Elegant. You'd never guess it's 20 Years Old. Great balance between salt and soft fruit.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 The Glenrothes  The Glenrothes 

1971

ABV 43.0%

Comments: An improbably well-balanced and deliciously layered malt for it's age. An outstanding Speysider.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

  The Balvenie 

1968

ABV 50.8%

Comments: A rather unusual Balvenie but delicious nonetheless!

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 The Macallan  The Macallan 

1926, 60 Years Old

ABV 0.0%

Comments: A privilege to taste such an old whisky but I just cannot handle such woody astringency.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

  Glenfiddich 

1965 Vintage Reserve

ABV 47.8%

Comments: A playful whisky for one of such maturity. Starting very sweetly, but reluctant to reveal its secrets. Give it time to reveal its complexity.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 The Balvenie  The Balvenie 

12 Years Old, Double Wood

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Delicious.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Chieftain's  Chieftain's 

Glencadam 

1985, Aged 16 Years

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Attractive rather than complex, but very attractive at that.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Bowmore  Bowmore 

Voyage

ABV 56.0%

Comments: Port often leaves a toffeeish note, but not in this case. Perhaps needs a bit more maturity.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Yoichi  Yoichi 

10 Years Old

ABV 43.0%

Comments: In my books, whisky from one of the worlds top half dozen distilleries. One of my day-to-day drams.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 The Glenturret  The Glenturret 

21 Years Old

ABV 40.0%

Comments: A restrained malt for all its massive complexity and depth.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Old Malt Cask  Old Malt Cask 

Brora 

1999, Aged 18 Years

ABV 50.0%

Comments: More Islay-like than its Clynelish brothers. Was this some of the last made with highly peated malt?

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

  Glenmorangie 

Malaga Wood Finish, 25 Years Old

ABV 43.0%

Comments: Eye-catching, complex and downright deliciously unusual.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Glen Garioch  Glen Garioch 

1968, 29 Years Old

ABV 56.3%

Comments: A monster of a malt, fully underlining what truly magnificent distillery this once was when the peating levels were traditional and unrestrained.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Longmorn  Longmorn 

15 Years Old

ABV 45.0%

Comments: That frisky Speysider judiciously bottled at 45% has a lot to deliver. Will certainly light up a zen moment.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 The Tyrconnell  The Tyrconnell 

16 Years Old, Oloroso & Moscatel Cask Finish

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Takes you on a twisting journey though French vineyards and the undergrowth.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Teeling Whiskey  Teeling Whiskey 

Chestnut Cask finish

ABV 55.1%

Comments: The nose promised Narnia, but the palate takes you to frying bacon outside Tom Sawyer’s tent.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Lagavulin  Lagavulin 

12 Years Old

ABV 56.1%

Comments: Just what you'd expect and want from this distillery.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Balcones  Balcones 

Texas Single Malt Whiskey

ABV 64.0%

Comments: Really moreish, as those spices open up to make a really lovely and easily drinkable whisky.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Barr an Uisce  Barr an Uisce 

Barr an Uisce 

10 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: Not much wrong here, very easy to drink and enjoy.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Kavalan  Kavalan 

Distillery Reserve Peaty Cask

ABV 57.1%

Comments: Another well turned out and balanced Taiwanese whisky. Great stuff indeed.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Sullivans Cove  Sullivans Cove 

French Oak Cask Matured

ABV 47.5%

Comments: One for sherry fans. The nose was my favourite part.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 anCnoc  anCnoc 

Peatlands

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A light heated whisky. 10 points less if this had no smoke…

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Ardbeg  Ardbeg 

Supernova Committee Release

ABV 55.0%

Comments: A big boy bruiser with a tender heart.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 anCnoc  anCnoc 

22 Years Old

ABV 46.0%

Comments: A graceful whisky all well balanced and integrated too.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Bowmore  Bowmore 

1985

ABV 52.3%

Comments: Distinct, robust and delightfully elegant in the same glass. A classy offering indeed.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Glenglassaugh  Glenglassaugh 

The Chosen Few No.1 Ronnie Routledge 35 Years Old

ABV 49.6%

Comments: Complex and confident. Lovely stuff!

OVERALL SCORE

8.7

 Chivas Brothers  Chivas Brothers 

Inverleven 

Deoch an Dora, 1973, 36 Years Old

ABV 48.5%

Comments: A charming thirst-quencher. No water please. It is perfect straight.

OVERALL SCORE

8.7